Returning to the hot potato of the merits of the Premier League, I do tend to agree with the conclusion that the Premier League has, overall, had a negative effect on football in England.
However, the problem is that it's still the pinnacle league in England. And any sports team (or sportsman/woman) will try to achieve the highest progress they can. That's why they exist, and competitiveness is part of the human psyche. I don't doubt that Simon & Matthew speak honestly about their thoughts on their teams being promoted to the Premier League. And yet, apart from the financial aspect of being in the Prem, I think it likely that a not inconsiderable part of them would be jubillant at any promotion - simply because they've reached the top division, scaled the highest peak.
Just look at Blackpool fans. They know they've next to no chance of staying up but, like Burnley fans before them, will just enjoy the bigtime whilst it lasts, rubbing shoulders with the world-renowned clubs and seeing some of the best players in the world come to Bloomfield Road. You tell them that the Premier League is soulless and worse than the Championship. Ask them in which division they'd prefer to live life in.
Saint Snow wrote:
A fair analysis.
They say it is often better to travel hopefully than to actually arrive. That's what the Premier League is to me. It's something we have to aspire to because there is nothing else. It would signify the resurrection of a club which has, as is still said every time we're on TV, fallen from the Champions League semi-final to being 15 points adrift at the bottom of League One in just a few years. We've taken a fair bit of stick over those years, quite deservedly, but none of it was the fans' fault. Indeed all we did was provide teams with their big pay-days and ensured that League One continually boasted massive attendance figures relative to its status as 1,750,000 fans came through the turnstiles at Elland Road in our three year stay.
But promotion would be bitter sweet. Our realistic aspiration would be upper mid table after, say, five years. For a club with the heritage we have (after all we won the league more recently than Liverpool and were regularly in Europe in the 90s) that is a soulless and depressing thought. And for the privilege we would have to pay massive prices and have our kick offs shunted around left right and centre.
I would be jubilant at promotion, yes. But it isn't that long ago we were playing in the Premier League, and some still view it as their right (conveniently forgetting about the 80s wasteland that afflicted the club). We didn't travel to Old Trafford as day trippers. Those 9,000 fans weren't there to enjoy the day. They were there to snarl at the rest of the football world. When I went to Spurs there was no awe. It was the type of ground I have been used to watching Leeds in. In short promotion to the PL would simply be business as usual after the novelty had worn off. Except the world has moved on since 2002. Not even a club of our size can catch up - look at Villa and Everton as examples.
Blackpool, on the other hand, well to them it IS all new. Of course it meant a lot because in modern times they have no history. Generations have been and gone since it was a normal sight at Bloomfield Road for the top talent to turn up for them. I bet relegation, if it happens, will actually hurt them far more than they might admit.
Which grounds in the Premier League WOULDN'T I be excited about visiting? Ones where I can think of better in the Championship?
Blackpool, Wolves, Blackburn, Birmingham, Sunderland, Bolton, Fulham, Stoke, Wigan, West Brom.
This isn't meant to sound arrogant, just honest. I'm not sure I could stomach paying £50 to watch Leeds v Fulham on a Tuesday evening for the privilege of being ten points outside the Europa League place. What IS the point of that existence?
Farnley/Pudsey Leeds
40m asl