Remove ads from site

Essan
  • Essan
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
18 July 2013 09:50:27

Rather than take the Model thread off topic, I thought it better to start a new thread to discuss this.  


The puzzle for me is the Meto MRF's, the Meto forecasts were hopeless at predicted the arrival of the heat wave despite cross model support at the end of June and have wrongly been predicting a breakdown in the 7-10 day timeframe since it arrived. If I was involved in the UK tourism industry I would be furious as they seem to be endlessly talking down the UK summer weather.

So much for the Meto GW bias, it's exactly the opposite!

I am a fan of Meto forecasts but the MRFs have been appalling this summer and could have cost the UK Tourism industry lot of money.

Originally Posted by: Andy Woodcock 




Andy's comments recieved several votes of support in the model thread.   But how accurate is this?

Here is a selection of MetO 15-30 day outlooks since the beginning of July:

UK Outlook for Tuesday 16 Jul 2013 to Tuesday 30 Jul 2013: 


There are signals that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month should continue across most parts of the UK during at least the first half of this period. This means rainfall should be below average, with mainly above-average temperatures and above-average sunshine amounts.


Updated: 1141 on Mon 1 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Thursday 18 Jul 2013 to Thursday 1 Aug 2013:


Early indications are that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month could continue across many parts of the UK, especially the south. This implies below average rainfall and mainly above-average temperatures and above-average sunshine amounts. However, confidence decreases with time through this forecast period.


Updated: 1218 on Wed 3 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Sunday 21 Jul 2013 to Sunday 4 Aug 2013:


Early indications are that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month could continue across some parts of the UK, more likely in the south. This implies below average rainfall and mainly above average temperatures and above average sunshine amounts. However, later in the month and into the start of August more generally unsettled conditions look increasingly likely.


Updated: 1202 on Sat 6 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Thursday 25 Jul 2013 to Thursday 8 Aug 2013:


The balance of probability suggests conditions in late July being fairly similar to those of mid-July. As such southern regions are most likely to see periods of dry and settled weather with above average sunshine and temperatures and below average rainfall. Northern regions, meanwhile, remain most likely to be affected by bouts of changeable, unsettled weather. There are then some signs of some of these more changeable conditions spreading further south during early August.


Updated: 1229 on Wed 10 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Monday 29 Jul 2013 to Monday 12 Aug 2013:


The balance of probability suggests conditions in late July being fairly similar to those of mid-July. As such southern regions are most likely to see periods of dry and settled weather with above average sunshine, above average temperatures both day and night, and below average rainfall. Northern parts, meanwhile, are most likely to be affected by bouts of changeable, unsettled weather. This suggests some occasional spells of rain or showers, sometimes cooler conditions, but also some drier and brighter periods mixed in. There are then some signs of these more changeable conditions spreading further south at times into August.


Updated: 1159 on Sun 14 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Thursday 1 Aug 2013 to Thursday 15 Aug 2013:


There is a good deal of uncertainty during this period. Currently there are some indications that northern parts of the UK will most likely be unsettled with outbreaks of rain, but some drier and brighter interludes at times. Meanwhile, southern areas seem rather more likely on balance to hold onto the fine and settled and sometimes warm weather, although there is an overall increased likelihood that rather more unsettled and less warm conditions may affect southern areas at times.


Updated: 1240 on Wed 17 Jul 2013



Obviously we do not yet know what the weather will be like in August!

But I don't think it's at all fair to claim the MetO have been constantly predicting a breakdown in a 7-10 day timeframe when the 15-30 day outlooks have consistently referenced a continuation of fine weather, at least in the south (and, foc ourse, it has been unsettled at times this month in the north)   Yes, they have been suggesting a breakdown towards the end of July/beginning of August - which currently looks like happening perhaps a bit sooner than they have been predicting of late. 

IMO the British tourist industry has no cause for complaint this year.


Andy
Evesham, Worcs, Albion - 35m asl
Weather & Earth Science News 

Anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job - DNA
Rob K
18 July 2013 09:56:56
I agree. Where I think the mid-range forecasts failed was at the beginning of July where it was clear from the models that we were heading for a decent warm spell but the Met Office seemed very slow indeed to get on board. When the charts were predicting sunshine and temps into the high 20s for the first weekend of July (6/7th), the Met Office was still very much on the fence.

I took particular interest in that weekend as it was a family wedding, and I was reasonably confident 7 days beforehand that it was going to be a hot one. The Met, however, continued to suggest unsettled conditions coming from the north until much later.
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl
"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome
Essan
  • Essan
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
18 July 2013 10:04:23

I agree. Where I think the mid-range forecasts failed was at the beginning of July where it was clear from the models that we were heading for a decent warm spell but the Met Office seemed very slow indeed to get on board. When the charts were predicting sunshine and temps into the high 20s for the first weekend of July (6/7th), the Met Office was still very much on the fence.

Originally Posted by: Rob K 



I'm not sure they were?

UK Outlook for Thursday 4 Jul 2013 to Saturday 13 Jul 2013:


Any outbreaks of rain on Thursday will mainly be across northwestern parts of the United Kingdom, with southern and especially southeastern areas having a dry day with some sunshine. Indications are that the generally fine and dry weather across southern parts of the UK will extend further north with time with a relatively settled spell of weather developing across most areas. There is still a chance of spells of rain at times, but these should be less frequent and become restricted mainly to northern parts of the UK. Temperatures will generally be close to average at first, but it is likely to turn increasingly warm in the south through next week, and it may become very warm in the southeast.


Updated: 1130 on Sat 29 Jun 2013



UK Outlook for Saturday 6 Jul 2013 to Monday 15 Jul 2013:


There is reasonable confidence that high pressure will persist across the UK, giving mostly fine and dry conditions with a mixture of variable cloud and sunshine. Some glancing blows from Atlantic weather fronts are still possible across far northwestern parts, bringing some cloud and rain with cooler and breezier conditions at times, mainly western Scotland and perhaps Northern Ireland. Lighter winds elsewhere with temperatures around or rather above normal at first, but a good chance of increasingly warm temperatures during the course of the following week, especially inland, becoming locally very warm in sunny conditions. There is a chance that isolated late afternoon showers may develop inland with this warmth. There are some signals that the high pressure could possibly ease away to introduce slightly less settled conditions by mid-month.


Updated: 1140 on Mon 1 Jul 2013





btw I'm endebted to Stuart on Net-wx for running threads in which all these outlooks are posted for posterity


http://forum.netweather.tv/topic/64157-meto-uk-further-outlook/


http://forum.netweather.tv/topic/75951-met-office-16-to-30-day-outlook/


Andy
Evesham, Worcs, Albion - 35m asl
Weather & Earth Science News 

Anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job - DNA
nsrobins
18 July 2013 10:09:17

Thanks for that Andy - and answered my question in the MO thread.


So, where are people getting the idea that the Met Office predicted a wet Summer? Not the Daily Express surely.


Neil
Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)
Stormchaser, Member TORRO
David M Porter
18 July 2013 20:29:18


Rather than take the Model thread off topic, I thought it better to start a new thread to discuss this.  


The puzzle for me is the Meto MRF's, the Meto forecasts were hopeless at predicted the arrival of the heat wave despite cross model support at the end of June and have wrongly been predicting a breakdown in the 7-10 day timeframe since it arrived. If I was involved in the UK tourism industry I would be furious as they seem to be endlessly talking down the UK summer weather.

So much for the Meto GW bias, it's exactly the opposite!

I am a fan of Meto forecasts but the MRFs have been appalling this summer and could have cost the UK Tourism industry lot of money.

Originally Posted by: Essan 




Andy's comments recieved several votes of support in the model thread.   But how accurate is this?

Here is a selection of MetO 15-30 day outlooks since the beginning of July:

UK Outlook for Tuesday 16 Jul 2013 to Tuesday 30 Jul 2013: 


There are signals that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month should continue across most parts of the UK during at least the first half of this period. This means rainfall should be below average, with mainly above-average temperatures and above-average sunshine amounts.


Updated: 1141 on Mon 1 Jul 2013

Originally Posted by: Andy Woodcock 


UK Outlook for Thursday 18 Jul 2013 to Thursday 1 Aug 2013:


Early indications are that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month could continue across many parts of the UK, especially the south. This implies below average rainfall and mainly above-average temperatures and above-average sunshine amounts. However, confidence decreases with time through this forecast period.


Updated: 1218 on Wed 3 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Sunday 21 Jul 2013 to Sunday 4 Aug 2013:


Early indications are that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month could continue across some parts of the UK, more likely in the south. This implies below average rainfall and mainly above average temperatures and above average sunshine amounts. However, later in the month and into the start of August more generally unsettled conditions look increasingly likely.


Updated: 1202 on Sat 6 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Thursday 25 Jul 2013 to Thursday 8 Aug 2013:


The balance of probability suggests conditions in late July being fairly similar to those of mid-July. As such southern regions are most likely to see periods of dry and settled weather with above average sunshine and temperatures and below average rainfall. Northern regions, meanwhile, remain most likely to be affected by bouts of changeable, unsettled weather. There are then some signs of some of these more changeable conditions spreading further south during early August.


Updated: 1229 on Wed 10 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Monday 29 Jul 2013 to Monday 12 Aug 2013:


The balance of probability suggests conditions in late July being fairly similar to those of mid-July. As such southern regions are most likely to see periods of dry and settled weather with above average sunshine, above average temperatures both day and night, and below average rainfall. Northern parts, meanwhile, are most likely to be affected by bouts of changeable, unsettled weather. This suggests some occasional spells of rain or showers, sometimes cooler conditions, but also some drier and brighter periods mixed in. There are then some signs of these more changeable conditions spreading further south at times into August.


Updated: 1159 on Sun 14 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Thursday 1 Aug 2013 to Thursday 15 Aug 2013:


There is a good deal of uncertainty during this period. Currently there are some indications that northern parts of the UK will most likely be unsettled with outbreaks of rain, but some drier and brighter interludes at times. Meanwhile, southern areas seem rather more likely on balance to hold onto the fine and settled and sometimes warm weather, although there is an overall increased likelihood that rather more unsettled and less warm conditions may affect southern areas at times.


Updated: 1240 on Wed 17 Jul 2013



Obviously we do not yet know what the weather will be like in August!

But I don't think it's at all fair to claim the MetO have been constantly predicting a breakdown in a 7-10 day timeframe when the 15-30 day outlooks have consistently referenced a continuation of fine weather, at least in the south (and, foc ourse, it has been unsettled at times this month in the north)   Yes, they have been suggesting a breakdown towards the end of July/beginning of August - which currently looks like happening perhaps a bit sooner than they have been predicting of late. 

IMO the British tourist industry has no cause for complaint this year.



There has been very little by way of unsettled weather up here this month Andy that I know of, save for the first 3-4 days of July. The last time I saw any appreciable rain was on Tuesday 2nd July from a LP system that came in from the atlantic. There was another front that came in a couple of days later which produced rather less rain that two days before (there was very little rain if indeed any that day in Kingussie where I was at that time). I returned home from my holiday in the Highlands on Sat 6th July and have seen no appreciable rainfall at all in the 12 days since then. Yes, the far NW has been less sunny this week and a little damper, but not what I'd call proper unsettled weather. In fact, it has been so dry here just like most of the UK that my back lawn in now going brown in places; this has hardly happened if indeed at all since the scorching 1995 summer.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"Let us not take ourselves too seriously. None of us has a monopoly on wisdom, and we must always be ready to listen and respect other points of view."- Queen Elizabeth II 1926-2022
Andy Woodcock
19 July 2013 07:27:14

People have short memories, the MetO issued a statement on the 20th June stating that due to high SST in the Atlantic the UK can expect another decade of poor summers (by implication this to most people was a indication of what should be expected in summer 2013).


On the 28th June the MetO 10 dayer was still less than enthusiastic about the coming heatwave and when it arrived on the 5th July they expected it to breakdown within 10 days.


I am a MetO fan as anyone who reads my posts on TWO will know but the MetO failed to pick up on the intensity and length of the current heatwave despite cross model agreement in advance.


Caution by the MetO maybe, but away from the Weather Geek Community people are critical (just ask your friends) and if this weather continues and summer 2013 turns out a BBQ summer then the MetO reputation will have taken a hit.


To pretend otherwise is burying your head in the sand.


Andy 


Andy Woodcock
Penrith
Cumbria

Altitude 535 feet

"Why are the British so worried about climate change? Any change to their climate can only be an improvement" John Daley 2001
Andy Woodcock
19 July 2013 07:32:02


Rather than take the Model thread off topic, I thought it better to start a new thread to discuss this.  


The puzzle for me is the Meto MRF's, the Meto forecasts were hopeless at predicted the arrival of the heat wave despite cross model support at the end of June and have wrongly been predicting a breakdown in the 7-10 day timeframe since it arrived. If I was involved in the UK tourism industry I would be furious as they seem to be endlessly talking down the UK summer weather.

So much for the Meto GW bias, it's exactly the opposite!

I am a fan of Meto forecasts but the MRFs have been appalling this summer and could have cost the UK Tourism industry lot of money.

Originally Posted by: Essan 




Andy's comments recieved several votes of support in the model thread.   But how accurate is this?

Here is a selection of MetO 15-30 day outlooks since the beginning of July:

UK Outlook for Tuesday 16 Jul 2013 to Tuesday 30 Jul 2013: 


There are signals that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month should continue across most parts of the UK during at least the first half of this period. This means rainfall should be below average, with mainly above-average temperatures and above-average sunshine amounts.


Updated: 1141 on Mon 1 Jul 2013

Originally Posted by: Andy Woodcock 


UK Outlook for Thursday 18 Jul 2013 to Thursday 1 Aug 2013:


Early indications are that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month could continue across many parts of the UK, especially the south. This implies below average rainfall and mainly above-average temperatures and above-average sunshine amounts. However, confidence decreases with time through this forecast period.


Updated: 1218 on Wed 3 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Sunday 21 Jul 2013 to Sunday 4 Aug 2013:


Early indications are that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month could continue across some parts of the UK, more likely in the south. This implies below average rainfall and mainly above average temperatures and above average sunshine amounts. However, later in the month and into the start of August more generally unsettled conditions look increasingly likely.


Updated: 1202 on Sat 6 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Thursday 25 Jul 2013 to Thursday 8 Aug 2013:


The balance of probability suggests conditions in late July being fairly similar to those of mid-July. As such southern regions are most likely to see periods of dry and settled weather with above average sunshine and temperatures and below average rainfall. Northern regions, meanwhile, remain most likely to be affected by bouts of changeable, unsettled weather. There are then some signs of some of these more changeable conditions spreading further south during early August.


Updated: 1229 on Wed 10 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Monday 29 Jul 2013 to Monday 12 Aug 2013:


The balance of probability suggests conditions in late July being fairly similar to those of mid-July. As such southern regions are most likely to see periods of dry and settled weather with above average sunshine, above average temperatures both day and night, and below average rainfall. Northern parts, meanwhile, are most likely to be affected by bouts of changeable, unsettled weather. This suggests some occasional spells of rain or showers, sometimes cooler conditions, but also some drier and brighter periods mixed in. There are then some signs of these more changeable conditions spreading further south at times into August.


Updated: 1159 on Sun 14 Jul 2013


UK Outlook for Thursday 1 Aug 2013 to Thursday 15 Aug 2013:


There is a good deal of uncertainty during this period. Currently there are some indications that northern parts of the UK will most likely be unsettled with outbreaks of rain, but some drier and brighter interludes at times. Meanwhile, southern areas seem rather more likely on balance to hold onto the fine and settled and sometimes warm weather, although there is an overall increased likelihood that rather more unsettled and less warm conditions may affect southern areas at times.


Updated: 1240 on Wed 17 Jul 2013



Obviously we do not yet know what the weather will be like in August!

But I don't think it's at all fair to claim the MetO have been constantly predicting a breakdown in a 7-10 day timeframe when the 15-30 day outlooks have consistently referenced a continuation of fine weather, at least in the south (and, foc ourse, it has been unsettled at times this month in the north)   Yes, they have been suggesting a breakdown towards the end of July/beginning of August - which currently looks like happening perhaps a bit sooner than they have been predicting of late. 

IMO the British tourist industry has no cause for complaint this year.



Hmmm,


Lets see quotes from late June which are much less convincing.


By the 1st July the heatwave express was a few days away, the skill was predicting its arrival, length and intensity over a week away, they didnt.


Andy


Andy Woodcock
Penrith
Cumbria

Altitude 535 feet

"Why are the British so worried about climate change? Any change to their climate can only be an improvement" John Daley 2001
Essan
  • Essan
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
19 July 2013 12:09:02


People have short memories, the MetO issued a statement on the 20th June stating that due to high SST in the Atlantic the UK can expect another decade of poor summers (by implication this to most people was a indication of what should be expected in summer 2013).

Originally Posted by: Andy Woodcock 



The MetO made no prediction for a 'decade of washout summers' - that was just something the media made up.


On the 28th June the MetO 10 dayer was still less than enthusiastic about the coming heatwave and when it arrived on the 5th July they expected it to breakdown within 10 days.



The 15 day forecast on the 28th June read:


UK Outlook for Wednesday 3 Jul 2013 to Friday 12 Jul 2013:


Unsettled conditions with outbreaks of rain on Wednesday and Thursday, perhaps persistent and sometimes heavy over northwestern parts, whilst southeastern parts may become drier and brighter on Thursday. Thereafter, there are indications that a relatively settled spell of weather will develop across many parts of the UK. However, further spells of rain are likely at times, but these should be less frequent and become increasingly restricted to northern parts of the UK. The overall trend through next week is for the weather across southern parts of the UK to become predominately fine and dry and for these conditions to gradually extend further north with time. Temperatures will generally be close to average at first, turning increasingly warm in the south through next week, perhaps very warm in the southeast.


Updated: 1148 on Fri 28 Jun 2013



Sounds fairly enthusiastic to me?


And on the 5th they said:

UK Outlook for Wednesday 10 Jul 2013 to Friday 19 Jul 2013:


Conditions look likely to be fine, dry and settled with some long sunny spells across much of the UK throughout this period. It may often be cloudier across some northwestern parts of the UK with a risk of a little light rain. There is also a low risk of an isolated afternoon heavy shower developing over hills later next week and perhaps some cloudier conditions around North Sea and Irish Sea coastal areas. Away from the far northwest, it will be warm or very warm, and locally hot over inland central and southern areas. Towards the end of the period, it may turn more unsettled across northern Britain, with occasional rain or showers, while mostly dry, fine and warm weather is expected to continue across many southern parts.


Updated: 1121 on Fri 5 Jul 2013

UK Outlook for Saturday 20 Jul 2013 to Saturday 3 Aug 2013:


Early indications are that the dry and settled weather from the first half of the month could continue across many parts of the UK, especially the south. This implies below average rainfall and mainly above average temperatures and above average sunshine amounts. However, confidence decreases with time through this forecast period.


Updated: 1222 on Fri 5 Jul 2013



No mention of a breakdown at all, though they rightly mention decreasing confidence towards the end of the 30 day period - just as well since a breakdown does indeed look like happening before the end of that period.



I thnk that sometimes our memories play tricks, and sometimes when we see things that support what we think we remember (like idiots in newspapers still referring to the fictional 'wet summer forecast') it reinforces a false memory which then becomes lodged in our brains as fact ..... 


Andy
Evesham, Worcs, Albion - 35m asl
Weather & Earth Science News 

Anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job - DNA
Rob K
19 July 2013 15:24:34
Fair point, I was quite surprised to see those forecasts from late June as I could have sworn they were less positive at that time. Your point about false memories might be a good one!
Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl
"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome
glenogle
20 July 2013 12:22:59


 



But I don't think it's at all fair to claim the MetO have been constantly predicting a breakdown in a 7-10 day timeframe when the 15-30 day outlooks have consistently referenced a continuation of fine weather, at least in the south (and, foc ourse, it has been unsettled at times this month in the north)   Yes, they have been suggesting a breakdown towards the end of July/beginning of August - which currently looks like happening perhaps a bit sooner than they have been predicting of late. 

IMO the British tourist industry has no cause for complaint this year.


Originally Posted by: David M Porter 


There has been very little by way of unsettled weather up here this month Andy that I know of, save for the first 3-4 days of July. The last time I saw any appreciable rain was on Tuesday 2nd July from a LP system that came in from the atlantic. There was another front that came in a couple of days later which produced rather less rain that two days before (there was very little rain if indeed any that day in Kingussie where I was at that time). I returned home from my holiday in the Highlands on Sat 6th July and have seen no appreciable rainfall at all in the 12 days since then. Yes, the far NW has been less sunny this week and a little damper, but not what I'd call proper unsettled weather. In fact, it has been so dry here just like most of the UK that my back lawn in now going brown in places; this has hardly happened if indeed at all since the scorching 1995 summer.



The cloud in the north west has kept a lid on temps recently and has came and gone intermittently.


I was over west on Thursday and was 26/27 degrees most of the day.  Got to rest and be thankful and the cloud started, by the time i got over towards Inveraray the window wipers were on and it was 17degrees


UserPostedImage LLTNP 105m asl 
Users browsing this topic

    Remove ads from site

    Ads