Remove ads from site

Grandad
07 February 2015 21:56:45


 


It is correct to take the data for the 09z to 09z period. However, you need to remember that the maximum figure for that period is thrown back to the previous day whereas the minimum is not. So for example the maximum temperature in the 24 hours to 09z today is taken as the maximum for the 6th. Whereas the minimum for the 24 hours to 09z today is the minimum for the 7th.


To get the most accurate data you should use the actual maximum and minimum for the sites rather than just the hourly figures. The maximum and minimum for Stonyhurst are not available publicly so for that station you do have to use the hourly data.


It is normal to get some sort of downward adjustment at the end of the month. Sometimes is can be small and on other occasions it has been as high as 0.5C. When I investigated this some time back it appeared to be because the provisional data reported by Hadley is not based on the actual CET stations but a number of other stations some of which are not even in the CET area. No idea why this is.


Originally Posted by: Global Warming 


 


GW.. Thanks for this information. If you have been through it all before then I'm sorry to have bothered you.


To me it just seems strange that they cannot pick up four figues and scan 23 numbers to get the max and min without getting it wrong. Then, to end up with 6 numbers and calculate an average from them could be automated in 10 mins and be run automaticaaly.


How weird.

ARTzeman
07 February 2015 23:30:57

It is even weirder if you do an average each time of the post that I make. Remembering 3 of those  ..Met Office Hadley, N-W and Metcheck are collective figures . Mount Sorrel and my own are single. .. Not enough posters on here YET that put their own figures  to take into account.






Some people walk in the rain.
Others just get wet.
I Just Blow my horn or trumpet
Grandad
08 February 2015 09:23:19


It is even weirder if you do an average each time of the post that I make. Remembering 3 of those  ..Met Office Hadley, N-W and Metcheck are collective figures . Mount Sorrel and my own are single. .. Not enough posters on here YET that put their own figures  to take into account.


Originally Posted by: ARTzeman 


Art


I guess I am just lazy and wait for your figure for the daily CET rather than looking for myself!


I hadn't appreciated that what is purported to be the 'daily data to date' figure quoted on the Met Office CET figures page was not the actual CET figure for that day. It is for a different set of stations.


I only noticed it at the very beginning of the month when there was a large difference in my figure (I live in the middle of the  CET region) so when I saw your daily figure for the CET, I checked  to find out what the actual figure was from the three CET stations quoted and it was different by about 1C from the figure shown on the CET page.


I now understand (following GW's post above) why the adjustments have to be made at the end of the month, though I still find it strange that  they do not show the correct CET values each day when it would take no effort to do so..


It is a cause for confusion and I am sorry, but  I am a stickler for correct data. 

Global Warming
08 February 2015 10:49:52

I agree there is no logic as to why more accurate data is not posted by Hadley each day. On the 1st of each month they manage to post official final data for each day of the previous month, including the data for the final day.


The table below shows the data for January including my daily calculations of the CET, the provisional Hadley data and the final data. As you can see the Hadley data is sometimes massively revised at the end of the month. The most inaccurate day in January was the 23rd when the Hadley data was revised down by a massive 1.7C from the provisional data. Hence why I always caution that the provisional Hadley data should basically be ignored as it is sometimes very inaccurate.


ARTzeman
08 February 2015 11:15:10

Met Office Hadley    1.7c.   Anomaly    -2.8c.    Provisional to 7th.


Metcheck                1.36c. Anomaly    -2.84c.


N-W                       1.61c. Anomaly    -2.6c.


Mount Sorrel           1.7c.   Anomaly    -2.5c.


My Mean                 0.9c.   Anomaly    -4.9c.  






Some people walk in the rain.
Others just get wet.
I Just Blow my horn or trumpet
Grandad
08 February 2015 17:17:30


I agree there is no logic as to why more accurate data is not posted by Hadley each day. On the 1st of each month they manage to post official final data for each day of the previous month, including the data for the final day.


The table below shows the data for January including my daily calculations of the CET, the provisional Hadley data and the final data. As you can see the Hadley data is sometimes massively revised at the end of the month. The most inaccurate day in January was the 23rd when the Hadley data was revised down by a massive 1.7C from the provisional data. Hence why I always caution that the provisional Hadley data should basically be ignored as it is sometimes very inaccurate.



Originally Posted by: Global Warming 


Thankyou GW.


I will refrain from posting on each daily change as you are clearly already collecting the data.


I did find tha above interesting,if its not too much effort to produce could you produce it on a regular montly basis? 

Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
08 February 2015 20:48:27


It is even weirder if you do an average each time of the post that I make. Remembering 3 of those  ..Met Office Hadley, N-W and Metcheck are collective figures . Mount Sorrel and my own are single. .. Not enough posters on here YET that put their own figures  to take into account.


Originally Posted by: ARTzeman 

Art, it would be interesting to see how much the CET actually differs from the daily mean of individual locations.  However, it would only work if people actually collected temperatures accurately and as clinically as the official CET stations do.  I don't have a Stevenson screen and I know my stations don't record accurately.  They serve well for my own records but I couldn't use my daily means for comparison to others.


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.
Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.
ARTzeman
09 February 2015 11:30:59

Met Office Hadley     1.9c.   Anomaly     -2.5c.  Provisional to 8th.


Metcheck                 1.65c.  Anomaly    -2.55c.


N-W                        1.75c.  Anomaly    -2.46c.


Mount   Sorrel          2.1c.    Anomaly    -2.1c.


My   Mean                1.1.     Anomaly    -4.7c.


 






Some people walk in the rain.
Others just get wet.
I Just Blow my horn or trumpet
Frost Hollow
09 February 2015 16:04:07

Here:


-0.69c


Mean min -4.47c


Mean max 3.1c


 

Stormchaser
09 February 2015 21:03:58


Met Office Hadley     1.9c.   Anomaly     -2.5c.  Provisional to 8th.


Metcheck                 1.65c.  Anomaly    -2.55c.


N-W                        1.75c.  Anomaly    -2.46c.


Mount   Sorrel          2.1c.    Anomaly    -2.1c.


My   Mean                1.1.     Anomaly    -4.7c.


Originally Posted by: ARTzeman 


For some reason all three of these are notably above the mean IMBY which stands at 1.24*C to 8th.


Must admit that recent model output has been a cause for concern at times for the likes of myself right down in the sub-3*C predictions... but it does all depend on the positioning of what looks to be very strong and influential high pressure.


High latitude blocking was expected to be an influential feature for at least part of this month, but as yet there's little sign of it in the expected locations, but since late January the modeled behaviour of key background drivers (GWO/AAM) has changed in favour of such which favours mid-latitude blocking instead.


Oh well. Just have to hope it doesn't do too much damage!


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 
2023's Homeland Extremes:
T-Max: 30.2°C 9th Sep (...!) | T-Min: -7.1°C 22nd & 23rd Jan | Wettest Day: 25.9mm 2nd Nov | Ice Days: 1 (2nd Dec -1.3°C in freezing fog)
Keep Calm and Forecast On
Saint Snow
09 February 2015 22:33:53


Oh well. Just have to hope it doesn't do too much damage!


Originally Posted by: Stormchaser 


 


I think your CET estimate for Feb is looking way out, James. If I was picking it today, even with the current CET as it is, I'd go for over 4c, probably closer to 4.5c


 



Martin
Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)
A TWO addict since 14/12/01
"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."
Aneurin Bevan
ARTzeman
10 February 2015 11:12:47

Met Office Hadley      2.0c.   Anomaly    -2.3c.   Provisional to 9th.


Metcheck                  1.90c.  Anomaly    -2.30c.


N-W                        2.02c.   Anomaly   -2.19c.


Mount  Sorrel           2.3c.    Anomaly    -1.9c.


My  Mean                 1.1c.    Anomaly   -4.7c.   






Some people walk in the rain.
Others just get wet.
I Just Blow my horn or trumpet
Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
10 February 2015 22:19:21


I think your CET estimate for Feb is looking way out, James. If I was picking it today, even with the current CET as it is, I'd go for over 4c, probably closer to 4.5c


Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

    4c would suit me nicely, though I perhaps should have gone for 4.4c again, like I did last month.  However, I must not hope for too much and being at the top of the table is making me quite dizzy.


By the way, I had to explain to hubby why I was laughing when he handed me a pina colada as I lay on a sunbed on the beach!   I didn't spill it!   


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.
Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.
Stormchaser
10 February 2015 23:05:00


I think your CET estimate for Feb is looking way out, James. If I was picking it today, even with the current CET as it is, I'd go for over 4c, probably closer to 4.5c


Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 


So assuming above average temperatures all the way to month's end?


That much is still up in the air if you ask me. 


 


What I can see is that the CET will be close to my prediction at around the mid-point of the month so I'm not going to be living it easy 


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 
2023's Homeland Extremes:
T-Max: 30.2°C 9th Sep (...!) | T-Min: -7.1°C 22nd & 23rd Jan | Wettest Day: 25.9mm 2nd Nov | Ice Days: 1 (2nd Dec -1.3°C in freezing fog)
Keep Calm and Forecast On
KevBrads1
11 February 2015 06:49:27
I think 10th January-9th February CET is about 3.2C

Could we just go under 3C in the rolling 31 day average? 10th January was very mild.
MANCHESTER SUMMER INDEX for 2021: 238
Timelapses, old weather forecasts and natural phenomena videos can be seen on this site
http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgrSD1BwFz2feWDTydhpEhQ/playlists
ARTzeman
11 February 2015 13:00:53

Met Office Hadley         2.0c.    Anomaly   -2.03    Provisional to  9th   As not updated


Metcheck                     2.05c.   Anomaly    -2.15c.


N-W                             2.16c.   Anomaly    -2.05c.  


Mount  Sorrel               2.4c.     Anomaly    -1.8c.


My     Mean                 1.3c.     Anomaly     -4.5c.


   






Some people walk in the rain.
Others just get wet.
I Just Blow my horn or trumpet
Saint Snow
11 February 2015 13:49:50


 


So assuming above average temperatures all the way to month's end?


That much is still up in the air if you ask me. 


Originally Posted by: Stormchaser 


 


To paraphrase the old adage, two days is a long time in model output watching !


On the 9th, the trend was for increasing unsettledness as the month progressed. Now the models are hinting at either a more settled spell returning, or even a chilly evolution.


It wouldn't surprise me if the final figure was about halfway between your 2.4c and my 3.9c


But, course, the NWP rollercoaster has many a twist & turn



Martin
Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)
A TWO addict since 14/12/01
"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."
Aneurin Bevan
ARTzeman
12 February 2015 11:20:31

Met Office Hadley     2.2c.    Anomaly      -2.0c.   Provisional to  11th.   ....


Metcheck                    2.17c.  Anomaly        -2.03c.


N-W                           2.34c.  Anomaly        -1.87c.


Mount   Sorrel             2.5c.    Anomaly        -1.7c.


My     Mean                 1.5c.    Anomaly        -4.3c.                      






Some people walk in the rain.
Others just get wet.
I Just Blow my horn or trumpet
ARTzeman
13 February 2015 11:09:27

Met Office Hadley      2.5c.     Anomaly      -1.7c.   Provisional to 12th.


Metcheck                 2.29c.    Anomaly      -1.91c.


N-W                         2.45c     Anomaly      -1.76c.


Mount     Sorrel        2.6c.     Anomaly       -1.6c.


My    Mean               1.7c.     Anomaly       -4.0c.


      






Some people walk in the rain.
Others just get wet.
I Just Blow my horn or trumpet
Gavin P
13 February 2015 13:33:55

Looks like my colder than average February is a bust!


#herewegoagain


Rural West Northants 120m asl
Short, medium and long range weather forecast videos @ https://www.youtube.com/user/GavsWeatherVids
four
  • four
  • Advanced Member
13 February 2015 14:14:47

1.6C here so far, which is -1.9C


Caz
  • Caz
  • Advanced Member
13 February 2015 19:13:24


Met Office Hadley      2.5c.     Anomaly      -1.7c.   Provisional to 12th.


   


Originally Posted by: ARTzeman 


A question for the weather oracles on here please.  When the Met O show the anomaly, is it for the month up to that date, or is it for the whole month?  


For example:  above, the mean to 12th Feb is shown as 2.5c and the anomaly as -1.7c.  So does that mean the mean should be 4.2c up to 12th Feb, or is 4.2c the mean average for the month.


Market Warsop, North Nottinghamshire.
Join the fun and banter of the monthly CET competition.
Stormchaser
13 February 2015 20:38:29


Looks like my colder than average February is a bust!


#herewegoagain


Originally Posted by: Gavin P 


Maybe... maybe not.


The output features a lot of days with CET returns of 5-6*C as chilly nights (often not far from zero) mitigate mild days (8 to 10*C maximums).


A rough estimate using such values for the entire two weeks (not likely to happen but just to give a feel for things) produces a final CET close to 4*C which is still below average.


Not good enough for me of course, in fact it's higher than the original model-based estimate of 3.3*C - which I then adjusted downward due to strong signals for a disrupted vortex and blocking emerging .


The blocking has emerged, but it's not looking quite as chilly as I envisioned when looking ahead two weeks ago. Such is the fickle nature of long range predictions - it is literally impossible to make an accurate prediction for conditions more than two weeks away (this is scientific fact, the result of complexity escalating to the point where there are just too many possibilities to account for using the resources we have).


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 
2023's Homeland Extremes:
T-Max: 30.2°C 9th Sep (...!) | T-Min: -7.1°C 22nd & 23rd Jan | Wettest Day: 25.9mm 2nd Nov | Ice Days: 1 (2nd Dec -1.3°C in freezing fog)
Keep Calm and Forecast On
Stormchaser
13 February 2015 20:40:13


A question for the weather oracles on here please.  When the Met O show the anomaly, is it for the month up to that date, or is it for the whole month?  


For example:  above, the mean to 12th Feb is shown as 2.5c and the anomaly as -1.7c.  So does that mean the mean should be 4.2c up to 12th Feb, or is 4.2c the mean average for the month.


Originally Posted by: Caz 


This came up in January as well, IIRC it uses the LTA to the specific date 


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 
2023's Homeland Extremes:
T-Max: 30.2°C 9th Sep (...!) | T-Min: -7.1°C 22nd & 23rd Jan | Wettest Day: 25.9mm 2nd Nov | Ice Days: 1 (2nd Dec -1.3°C in freezing fog)
Keep Calm and Forecast On
Global Warming
13 February 2015 21:56:34


 


This came up in January as well, IIRC it uses the LTA to the specific date 


Originally Posted by: Stormchaser 


Correct. The data used on the Hadley page is the 1961-1990 mean. The mean for 1-12 Feb is 4.2C whereas the mean for the whole of Feb is 3.8C.

Remove ads from site

Ads