I'm presuming everyone watched the highlights and saw Liverpools first goal, what do we make of that? I'm pretty sure had it been one of the top 4 that ref would be banned from the top flight and made to do some Championship games!
I take your point Gooner about the top sides not losing as many games this season as they did last You must be paying to much attention to "those people that really know football"
Saint Snow wrote:
Given the benefit of replays, it's obvious that Turner was just knocking the ball toward his keeper, so he could take the free kick. However, there was a lead-up to this which the ref could argue is mitigation. First of all, Sunderland tried a quick free kick from the wrong place and the ref made them retake it in the right place. He actually tells Turner where to take it and Turner places the ball down, looking to take the kick. The ref then turns to check on the other players behind him. It's at this moment that Turner swivels and knocks the ball toward his keeper, Torres chases it down and so on. The linesman (or even 4th official) should have been the one to tell the ref what had actually happened.
First of all, Turner was stupid to do what he did - the ref had made a point of pinpointing the place for the FK to be taken and the ball had been placed there. Technically, he kicked the ball, thus resulting in a restart of the game.
Secondly, we've seen occassions before where a player has made a weak back-pass (even from a free kick) which a sharp opposing player has capitalised on. How was the ref to know this wasn't such an instance? What if a player makes a genuinely poor pass from a FK, which is intercepted, but claims to have just been kicking the ball to his teammmate to take the FK? Or, more likely, when there's a mix-up at a free kick near the opponent's box where 2 or 3 players are gathered round the ball; one touches it to set another up but there's a mix up and the opponent intent on charging the free kick down runs forward and nicks the ball before it's struck toward goal. Where is the line drawn?
I'd say that in the spirit of the game, the goal should have been ruled out. But technically, it was a goal.
It also sort of even out the beachball goal last season which, if strictly following the rules, should have been ruled out.
wallaw wrote: