Remove ads from site

Frostbite80
05 January 2015 10:05:43

Hi Mods, just wondering if you will let this topic stand alone as there seems to be a lot of talk on the Model thread about this and although a very interesting subject it would be nice to have two separate threads for those that are interested in one subject or the other or both rather than it all merging together, if not please delete.

Russwirral
05 January 2015 10:11:50
I think this thread has good reason to be here.

Just so we can baseline where we currently are with it... can anyone provide a simple statement on where we are with any SSW? or rather what is the current situation with the Strat?


Matty H
05 January 2015 10:12:24

If it helps some people throwing all their eggs in one basket on a factor that plays one small part in potentially bring cold weather to these shores, then I'm all for it. It also means that hopefully the MO thread can go back to discussing what the models are showing. 


Frostbite80
05 January 2015 10:25:51


If it helps some people throwing all their eggs in one basket on a factor that plays one small part in potentially bring cold weather to these shores, then I'm all for it. It also means that hopefully the MO thread can go back to discussing what the models are showing. 


Originally Posted by: Matty H 

That is exactly my intentions, I think some need to remember when we didn't even really know what a SSW actually was let alone discuss it and although it has it's part to play it is not the be all and end all of our winter here in blighty, it has been well proven that we do not need a SSW to have a cold spell and it has also been proven that a SSW does not always bring a cold spell to the UK, in fact more often than not it doesn't.


 


This is not to say that it is not a fascinating subject and I will be flicking through both threads but I think we need to be a little more level headed regarding it.


 


It may also be a good thread to talk about the MJO also as I can see that this is having it's fair share of discussion now, so if you would like me to update the title just say

Frostbite80
05 January 2015 16:46:48
Tbh I hope we don't get a ssw but we do get a cold spell if only to stop people resting all their hopes on just this one factor of many for cold blessing our shores!
Matty H
05 January 2015 21:37:44

We're far better at using paragraphs though 


05 January 2015 21:53:56

One thing I think we can be clear on is that the current warming event in the stratosphere has reached its peak and will gradually dissipate over the next few days. It has undoubtedly been the most significant warming event since January 2013 but arguably falls just short of the definition of even a minor SSW. We will have to wait and see if it does have any significant impact on weather in the coming weeks but I rather doubt it looking at the latest model output.


The greatest warming has been at the 2hPa and 5hPa levels with warming approaching 35C. To be classed as even a minor SSW the warming needs to be more than 25C within a week. The current warming has taken place over about a two and a half week period since mid December so not "sudden" enough to meet the criteria.


Mean temperature data for 5hPa and 2hPa up to yesterday for 65-90N


5hPa http://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/stratosphere/temperature/05mb9065.gif


2hPa http://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/stratosphere/temperature/02mb9065.gif


The other key aspect of a SSW is the reversal of the zonal winds. Now in fact we have seen a small reversal of the zonal winds at 70-90N. This chart is the forecast for 12z today from yesterday's ECM run which shows a negative zonal flow at all levels from 70 degrees north.


http://users.met.fu-berlin.de/~Aktuell/strat-www/wdiag/figs/ecmwf1/ecmwfzm_u_f24.gif


However, this reversal of the zonal winds is very short lived indeed and effectively peaked today. The forecasts for 9 Jan and 14 Jan below show we go back to a very positive zonal flow. So I can't see that the reversal of the zonal winds has been anything like long enough or substantial enough to make any noticeable impact on the weather at the surface in the next few weeks.


http://users.met.fu-berlin.de/~Aktuell/strat-www/wdiag/figs/ecmwf1/ecmwfzm_u_f120.gif


http://users.met.fu-berlin.de/~Aktuell/strat-www/wdiag/figs/ecmwf1/ecmwfzm_u_f240.gif

Matty H
05 January 2015 22:39:26

One thing I am absolutely certain of, is that some people place for too much emphasis on it as a cold trigger for the UK. 


Solar Cycles
06 January 2015 09:42:16


One thing I am absolutely certain of, is that some people place for too much emphasis on it as a cold trigger for the UK. 


Originally Posted by: Matty H 

Not really, it just loads the dice more in our favour Matty. Nothing more, nothing less!

David M Porter
06 January 2015 09:51:31

In the model thread earlier, Kevin Bradshaw mentioned January 1991 and January 2005 which both started off as zonal, sometimes stormy affairs but then became much quieter, and colder later on in the month. Both of those years then saw cold spells in February, 1991 especially so. Did either of those years have any strat warming events early on in the year or at the tail end of the preceding year?


Lenzie, Glasgow

"Let us not take ourselves too seriously. None of us has a monopoly on wisdom, and we must always be ready to listen and respect other points of view."- Queen Elizabeth II 1926-2022
Saint Snow
06 January 2015 10:06:05

I think some need to remember when we didn't even really know what a SSW actually was let alone discuss it


Originally Posted by: Frostbite80 


 


Just because we didn't know about them doesn't mean they weren't influencing our weather




Martin
Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)
A TWO addict since 14/12/01
"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."
Aneurin Bevan
Hippydave
06 January 2015 21:52:22


In the model thread earlier, Kevin Bradshaw mentioned January 1991 and January 2005 which both started off as zonal, sometimes stormy affairs but then became much quieter, and colder later on in the month. Both of those years then saw cold spells in February, 1991 especially so. Did either of those years have any strat warming events early on in the year or at the tail end of the preceding year?


Originally Posted by: David M Porter 


I'll freely admit to being pretty ignorant on SSWs but I did find this:-


http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2011JD016769/pdf 


Which suggests no SSW prior to Feb 1991, only goes to 2002 so no idea after that.


Some of the other papers I was reading through whilst pretending to work earlier, seemed to suggest that whilst SSW's can/do affect the trop weather patterns the latter can also be true i.e the trop drives the strat.  Must admit most of the stuff I found was fairly technical and went several miles over my head - not the kind of thing it's easy to pick up from reading academic jargon!


 


Home: Tunbridge Wells
Work: Tonbridge
Maunder Minimum
07 January 2015 07:19:42
The strat warming such as it is has now peaked :
http://users.met.fu-berlin.de/~Aktuell/strat-www/wdiag/ts.php?plot=temps#top 
Has not been sufficient to have an impact on the troposphere it would appear.
New world order coming.
nouska
07 January 2015 09:00:13


In the model thread earlier, Kevin Bradshaw mentioned January 1991 and January 2005 which both started off as zonal, sometimes stormy affairs but then became much quieter, and colder later on in the month. Both of those years then saw cold spells in February, 1991 especially so. Did either of those years have any strat warming events early on in the year or at the tail end of the preceding year?


Originally Posted by: David M Porter 


There's an animation of the warming in February 1991 on the Martineau site: it was classified as a technical SSW.


http://curriculum.pmartineau.webfactional.com/wp-content/svw_gallery/test/gif/1991_01_28.gif

Brian Gaze
07 January 2015 12:41:08

The strat warming such as it is has now peaked :
http://users.met.fu-berlin.de/~Aktuell/strat-www/wdiag/ts.php?plot=temps#top
Has not been sufficient to have an impact on the troposphere it would appear.

Originally Posted by: Maunder Minimum 


The MetO issued a statement several days ago saying this. As I mentioned at the time the press reporting and misunderstanding around this topic is now widespread. Those who are using it as a primary forecast signal are struggling more than anyone else this winter. That doesn't of course mean that it's not important.


Brian Gaze
Berkhamsted
TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 
"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan
Solar Cycles
07 January 2015 12:53:25


 


The MetO issued a statement several days ago saying this. As I mentioned at the time the press reporting and misunderstanding around this topic is now widespread. Those who are using it as a primary forecast signal are struggling more than anyone else this winter. That doesn't of course mean that it's not important.


Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

I remember at the start of the winter the MetO were indicating that there were  mixed signals from the GLOSEA 5 output with some pointing towards a colder than average winter but their model saw a +NAO. I would love to know what it was that was showing  as on the seasonal outlook it didn't really go into any detail on what these signals were.

Gavin P
07 January 2015 13:00:39

I have noticed over the past year or two (since the SSW event of January 2013) that any warming, anywhere within the vicinity of the North Pole is regarded as an SSW and there's an assumption that this must plunge us into the freezer.


If only the weather was that simple...


Rural West Northants 120m asl
Short, medium and long range weather forecast videos @ https://www.youtube.com/user/GavsWeatherVids
Solar Cycles
07 January 2015 13:05:36


I have noticed over the past year or two (since the SSW event of January 2013) that any warming, anywhere within the vicinity of the North Pole is regarded as an SSW and there's an assumption that this must plunge us into the freezer.


If only the weather was that simple...


Originally Posted by: Gavin P 

Lol, yes it's been quite an eye opener for us proponents of SSW and goes to show the damn weather will do just what it likes, although I'm sure there's countless other feedbacks we don't even know about as well as the one's we have little understanding of. Your forecasts is still looking good Gav, until February is breached at least.

Gavin P
07 January 2015 13:11:47


Lol, yes it's been quite an eye opener for us proponents of SSW and goes to show the damn weather will do just what it likes, although I'm sure there's countless other feedbacks we don't even know about as well as the one's we have little understanding of. Your forecasts is still looking good Gav, until February is breached at least.


Originally Posted by: Solar Cycles 


I need another cold snap (preferably with some snow) in January and then we come to the tricky part in February.


Rural West Northants 120m asl
Short, medium and long range weather forecast videos @ https://www.youtube.com/user/GavsWeatherVids
White Meadows
20 January 2015 12:41:39
Hi CC, thanks for the info.
As it looks like Strat discussion in the MO thread is now banned, I'll be coming in here to check any updates.
Jonesy
26 January 2015 12:18:43

So you wanted a SSW thread so much and yet I don't see that many updates on it  ....or is the reality there is no updates on SSW?


 


 


Medway Towns (Kent)
The Weather will do what it wants, when it wants, no matter what data is thrown at it !
Scandy 1050 MB
26 January 2015 13:44:23

Surprisingly quiet in here considering what is being forecast - we now have not one but two warming events with the latter one looking even better, going on the 06z GFS run:


 


This appears to be the peak of the first one at the moment - this was more intense originally but then downgraded and now slightly upgraded again:


 


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gfse_cartes.php?&ech=168&mode=10&carte=1


 


Then we have this one in FI which looks even more interesting:


 


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gfse_cartes.php?&ech=360&mode=10&carte=1


 


No guarantee that will have any effect on the lower atmosphere but warm heights like that are interesting as the possibility is there - is the GFS at the end of the run reacting to this?


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gfse_cartes.php?&ech=384&mode=0&carte=1


 


BTW, Keep up the SSW videos Gavin P, excellent stuff. 

David M Porter
08 February 2015 21:53:59

Nothing much happening in the stratosphere at the moment, I assume?


Lenzie, Glasgow

"Let us not take ourselves too seriously. None of us has a monopoly on wisdom, and we must always be ready to listen and respect other points of view."- Queen Elizabeth II 1926-2022
nsrobins
08 February 2015 22:15:01


Nothing much happening in the stratosphere at the moment, I assume?


Originally Posted by: David M Porter 


No



Neil
Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)
Stormchaser, Member TORRO
Brian Gaze
08 February 2015 22:20:37

The Lyrids occur in the second half of April so there could be an impact on the mesosphere then which may propagate down to the strat. 


Brian Gaze
Berkhamsted
TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 
"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan

Remove ads from site

Ads