Remove ads from site

Gandalf The White
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 12:20:41 AM

Interesting to note the run to run inconsistency of ECM.

Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 


Not if you use the ensemble mean rather than getting hung up on the inevitable variations of FI in the operational runs.


 


http://www.weathercast.co.uk/services/ensemble-forecast.html 


The Op is an extraordinary outlier on Day 10 and only just within the mildest 10% on Day 9. The mean remains in the cold category and is supported by the majority of the ensemble members, which continue to offer maxima around 5C falling to 3C and overnight frosts from Day 8.


There's very little support for anything above average for mid-December.


Location: South Cambridgeshire
130 metres ASL
52.0N 0.1E


Gandalf The White
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 12:24:28 AM




Nothing on the 18z to suggest any sort of blocking of the non-bartlett kind. Infact its a major downgrade from the 12z that was at least attempting to split the pv at 192. 


Originally Posted by: Quantum 


That's the second time you've moaned about Bartletts tonight. But I can't remember seeing a Bartlett modelled anywhere this autumn. In fact I can't off-hand remember a Bartlett anywhere throughout 2013.


For reference, a Bartlett is stationary high pressure over the Continent with mild westerlies off the Atlantic riding over the top and directly through the UK.


If you can show me one single example of that from recent output, I'll be grateful.


Originally Posted by: some faraway beach 


http://cdn.nwstatic.co.uk/ecmimages/20131203/12/npsh500.192.png


Originally Posted by: Quantum 


Q, that is not a Bartlett, that is a Euro high.  There's a fundamental difference - are you not aware?


A Bartlett describes a pattern not a specific chart.  It is a succession of high pressure cells moving west to east from the area of the Azores into continental Europe before sliding and/or fading away to be replaced by the next in the procession.


We have scarcely seen any charts this autumn or early winter that offer that pattern.


A Euro surface high developing from a surge of WAA is not the same beast at all.


Location: South Cambridgeshire
130 metres ASL
52.0N 0.1E


some faraway beach
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 12:27:12 AM




Nothing on the 18z to suggest any sort of blocking of the non-bartlett kind. Infact its a major downgrade from the 12z that was at least attempting to split the pv at 192. 


Originally Posted by: Quantum 


That's the second time you've moaned about Bartletts tonight. But I can't remember seeing a Bartlett modelled anywhere this autumn. In fact I can't off-hand remember a Bartlett anywhere throughout 2013.


For reference, a Bartlett is stationary high pressure over the Continent with mild westerlies off the Atlantic riding over the top and directly through the UK.


If you can show me one single example of that from recent output, I'll be grateful.


Originally Posted by: some faraway beach 


http://cdn.nwstatic.co.uk/ecmimages/20131203/12/npsh500.192.png


Originally Posted by: Quantum 


The whole of the UK is under high pressure on that chart. There are absolutely no mild winds off the Atlantic anywhere at all. That chart is the complete opposite of a Bartlett.


This is important, because a Bartlett to me implies the Azores High extending immovably over the Continent with no hope of any Northern blocking promoting cold for the UK. That chart you've posted shows the exact opposite - low pressure over the Azores, with high pressure over the UK which could alter shape and position in all sorts of ways.


2 miles west of Taunton, 32 m asl, where "milder air moving in from the west" becomes SNOWMAGEDDON.
Well, two or three times a decade it does, anyway.
some faraway beach
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 12:28:34 AM

Or as Gandalf put it more expertly ... 


2 miles west of Taunton, 32 m asl, where "milder air moving in from the west" becomes SNOWMAGEDDON.
Well, two or three times a decade it does, anyway.
nsrobins
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 12:33:24 AM


Interesting to note the run to run inconsistency of ECM.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


Not if you use the ensemble mean rather than getting hung up on the inevitable variations of FI in the operational runs.


 


http://www.weathercast.co.uk/services/ensemble-forecast.html 


The Op is an extraordinary outlier on Day 10 and only just within the mildest 10% on Day 9. The mean remains in the cold category and is supported by the majority of the ensemble members, which continue to offer maxima around 5C falling to 3C and overnight frosts from Day 8.


There's very little support for anything above average for mid-December.


Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 


Cheers Mithrandir - suspected as much. Very glad I came straight to this page and not waded through the last five or else I might be forgiven for thinking a very mild and settled spell was set in stone for the next two weeks


Neil
Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)
Stormchaser, Member TORRO
jan1987blizzard
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 12:43:21 AM


Interesting to note the run to run inconsistency of ECM.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


Not if you use the ensemble mean rather than getting hung up on the inevitable variations of FI in the operational runs.


 


http://www.weathercast.co.uk/services/ensemble-forecast.html 


The Op is an extraordinary outlier on Day 10 and only just within the mildest 10% on Day 9. The mean remains in the cold category and is supported by the majority of the ensemble members, which continue to offer maxima around 5C falling to 3C and overnight frosts from Day 8.


There's very little support for anything above average for mid-December.


Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 


 


And to add to that, its about the 4th or 5th mildest member only 3 or 4 days into the run so should be taken as an outlier solution for the time being at least.

Gandalf The White
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 12:55:51 AM


Interesting to note the run to run inconsistency of ECM.

Originally Posted by: nsrobins 


Not if you use the ensemble mean rather than getting hung up on the inevitable variations of FI in the operational runs.

http://www.weathercast.co.uk/services/ensemble-forecast.html 
The Op is an extraordinary outlier on Day 10 and only just within the mildest 10% on Day 9. The mean remains in the cold category and is supported by the majority of the ensemble members, which continue to offer maxima around 5C falling to 3C and overnight frosts from Day 8.
There's very little support for anything above average for mid-December.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


Cheers Mithrandir - suspected as much.Very glad I came straight to this page and not waded through the last five or else I might be forgiven for thinking a very mild and settled spell was set in stone for the next two weeks UserPostedImage

Originally Posted by: Whether Idle 



Mithrandir!? Another Tolkienist I detect... Thank you kindly.

I'll try to magic up something seasonal... and see if we can banish any mild-minded trolls along the way!
Matty, where are you? 😉
Location: South Cambridgeshire
130 metres ASL
52.0N 0.1E


Quantum
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 1:13:43 AM





Nothing on the 18z to suggest any sort of blocking of the non-bartlett kind. Infact its a major downgrade from the 12z that was at least attempting to split the pv at 192. 


Originally Posted by: some faraway beach 


That's the second time you've moaned about Bartletts tonight. But I can't remember seeing a Bartlett modelled anywhere this autumn. In fact I can't off-hand remember a Bartlett anywhere throughout 2013.


For reference, a Bartlett is stationary high pressure over the Continent with mild westerlies off the Atlantic riding over the top and directly through the UK.


If you can show me one single example of that from recent output, I'll be grateful.


Originally Posted by: Quantum 


http://cdn.nwstatic.co.uk/ecmimages/20131203/12/npsh500.192.png


Originally Posted by: some faraway beach 


The whole of the UK is under high pressure on that chart. There are absolutely no mild winds off the Atlantic anywhere at all. That chart is the complete opposite of a Bartlett.


This is important, because a Bartlett to me implies the Azores High extending immovably over the Continent with no hope of any Northern blocking promoting cold for the UK. That chart you've posted shows the exact opposite - low pressure over the Azores, with high pressure over the UK which could alter shape and position in all sorts of ways.


Originally Posted by: Quantum 


Why should a bartlett high be necessarily characturised by warm temperatures at the surface? The temperature of the airmass is mild. And the mild feed lasts from 96h to 240h, with the HP stuck over Europe, and LP to the north. How is that not a bartlett high?


 


EDIT: incidently I am not personally suggesting mild weather either, as my CET prediction will attest  everywhere, although NW scotland will see double figures I'm sure. 


Twitter: @QuantumOverlord (general), @MedicaneWatch (medicane/TC stuff)
2023/2024 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):
29/11 (-6), 30/11 (-6), 02/12 (-5), 03/12 (-5), 04/12 (-3), 16/01 (-3), 18/01 (-8), 08/02 (-5)

Total: 8 days with snow/sleet falling.

2022/2023 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):

18/12 (-1), 06/03 (-6), 08/03 (-8), 09/03 (-6), 10/03 (-8), 11/03 (-5), 14/03 (-6)

Total: 7 days with snow/sleet falling.

2021/2022 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):

26/11 (-5), 27/11 (-7), 28/11 (-6), 02/12 (-6), 06/01 (-5), 07/01 (-6), 06/02 (-5), 19/02 (-5), 24/02 (-7), 30/03 (-7), 31/03 (-8), 01/04 (-8)
Total: 12 days with snow/sleet falling.
Retron
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 3:29:19 AM

Blimey, I can't believe how people get suckered in by looking solely at the operational output! The ECM ensembles still show a colder spell in the medium term and the operational last night was a massive outlier by day 10. The control run was also a mild outlier by day 10 and it shows mildness continuing to day 15. The bulk of the ensemble members show a much colder outlook than the operational and control.

http://www.weathercast.co.uk/services/ensemble-forecast.html
http://oi42.tinypic.com/2n7me86.jpg

I know that won't convince the resident sceptics but if you actually look at the available output you can see that last night was just one of those coincidences when the operationals happened to be mild. Assuming the background signals remain there's nothing to say we won't see the colder cluster represented as an operational next time...


Leysdown, north Kent
Retron
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 4:02:07 AM


. How is that not a bartlett high?


Originally Posted by: Quantum 


It's clearly not one:


http://weatherfaqs.org.uk/node/117


"Rain, gales and above average temperatures prevail"


Leysdown, north Kent
Retron
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 5:04:21 AM
A very uninspiring GFS op although into low-res it does cool down a bit for much of England.

We're in for rather a quiet spell of weather it seems as the Euro high will lurk close by. The main issues are whether we pick up a chilly Continental feed (as with EPS) or whether the feed picks up more in the way of Atlantic gunk (GFS, GEFS).

Longer term, as in 10 days and beyond, there remain signals for a pressure build to the NE with EPS and although much fewer in number there continue to be similar options amongst the GEFS members.




Leysdown, north Kent
Retron
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:01:28 AM

Looking at the ECM this morning, I wonder if anyone will fall into the "orange trap*"? ;P


Orange trap - the act looking at a chart with lots of orange on it in winter and assuming it means mild!

http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm1681.gif


http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm2401.gif


Leysdown, north Kent
Gandalf The White
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:25:22 AM

Looking at the ECM this morning, I wonder if anyone will fall into the "orange trap*"? ;P


Orange trap - the act looking at a chart with lots of orange on it in winter and assuming it means mild!

http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm1681.gif


http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm2401.gif

Originally Posted by: Retron 



LOL Darren.

It's a pity we don't see more output from the ECM model, isn't it? The ensemble graphs give surface temperatures but we have to wait almost 12 hours to see it. As you say it won't show mild at the surface on this run. I'm expecting the run to run consistency to continue.

The way the high is fairly consistently modelled to edge and ridge north is encouraging. There's an awful lot of Arctic air moving south on the eastern flank of the high and it won't take much of a drift north of the High to start to advect it westwards. I think Nick mentioned "slow burn Easterly" a couple of days ago - might be an astute observation.
Location: South Cambridgeshire
130 metres ASL
52.0N 0.1E


eastcoaster
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:28:19 AM
Matty H
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:31:39 AM
GFS op has lots of orange on it and is mild whether anyone likes it or not. Naturally that's trolling 🙄

Temps into double figures for many out at T+138. ECM looks very similar.
Retron
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:31:41 AM



It's a pity we don't see more output from the ECM model, isn't it? The ensemble graphs give surface temperatures but we have to wait almost 12 hours to see it. As you say it won't show mild at the surface on this run. I'm expecting the run to run consistency to continue.


Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


Yes, it's a shame that you have to jump through hoops in order to get access to data which is, after all, prepared here in the UK!


I strongly suspect that when those London ensemble charts update later that they'll show mean maxima around 5C for much of the run with the GFS operational way out on its own again. To be fair the GFS has been consistent with that for a few runs now, but I reckon it's being consistently wrong rather than picking up on a trend which ECM has missed.


I think Nick mentioned "slow burn Easterly" a couple of days ago - might be an astute observation.


Indeed - as I've been saying for a while now the signs have been there for a week or so from ECM. The other models chop and change but the ECM ensembles (not the op!) have been remarkably consistent.


(EDIT - here's the London ECM ensemble link for those who've not bookmarked it).


Leysdown, north Kent
Retron
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:35:24 AM

GFS op has lots of orange on it and is mild whether anyone likes it or not. Naturally that's trolling RollEyes

Temps into double figures for many out at T+138. ECM looks very similar.

Originally Posted by: Matty H 


I'm saying no more until the ECM ensembles come out later. Other, that is, to say that Gandalf gets it even if no-one else does!


Leysdown, north Kent
Gandalf The White
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:37:40 AM

ECM looks mild this morning.

http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm1681.gif 

http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm2401.gif 

Originally Posted by: eastcoaster 



LOL - first victim of the day.... ;-)

See Darren's post above! Follow the isobars and see the flow of the airmass and consider mid-winter conditions over a continental landmass under high pressure.
Location: South Cambridgeshire
130 metres ASL
52.0N 0.1E


Matty H
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:38:59 AM

GFS op has lots of orange on it and is mild whether anyone likes it or not. Naturally that's trolling RollEyes

Temps into double figures for many out at T+138. ECM looks very similar.

Originally Posted by: Retron 


I'm saying no more until the ECM ensembles come out later. Other, that is, to say that Gandalf gets it even if no-one else does!

Originally Posted by: Matty H 



Gets what? Speculation or interpretation? Or is just cold trolling? What's good for the goose... 😉

Bottom line is both charts around that stage show mild weather. Temps in southern England are up to 13c on the GFS charts.

What happens further down the line may change of course, and anyone with half a brain knows that temps will gradually fall away at ground level under sustained high pressure during winter.

The main point of interest for me is how dry it will be. Gives me an incentive to wash the car knowing it won't be plastered in grime two days later 👍
Larry Seinfeld
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:39:25 AM

I hope the GFS surface temps are correct, from saturday here in Torquay we wouldn't drop into single figures day or night until the 20th December!


 


http://www.skystef.be/forecast19e.html


KevBrads1
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:43:35 AM

ECM looks mild this morning.

http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm1681.gif 

http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm2401.gif 

Originally Posted by: eastcoaster 




Looks mild but these Manchester 2m temps from it suggest not

http://www.yr.no/place/United_Kingdom/England/Manchester/long.html 

It also suggest anticyclonic gloom, oh joy! 😞
MANCHESTER SUMMER INDEX for 2021: 238
Timelapses, old weather forecasts and natural phenomena videos can be seen on this site
http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgrSD1BwFz2feWDTydhpEhQ/playlists
Gandalf The White
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:46:49 AM

GFS op has lots of orange on it and is mild whether anyone likes it or not. Naturally that's trolling RollEyes

Temps into double figures for many out at T+138. ECM looks very similar.

Originally Posted by: Matty H 


I'm saying no more until the ECM ensembles come out later. Other, that is, to say that Gandalf gets it even if no-one else does!

Originally Posted by: Retron 



Gets what? Speculation or interpretation? Or is just cold trolling? What's good for the goose... 😉

Bottom line is both charts around that stage show mild weather. Temps in southern England are up to 13c on the GFS charts.

What happens further down the line may change of course, and anyone with half a brain knows that temps will gradually fall away at ground level under sustained high pressure during winter.

The main point of interest for me is how dry it will be. Gives me an incentive to wash the car knowing it won't be plastered in grime two days later 👍

Originally Posted by: Matty H 



I think you're comparing apples and oranges.....

It's the uppers in conjunction with the synoptics and GFS brings the airmass from a mild source which ECM does not.

A rare occasion when we're all right...!

If GFS is modelling the evolution correctly it may well be mild - if the High is positioned such that we get a SE component to the flow then mild it won't be (away from western coastal areas - maybe covering Yate...)

Location: South Cambridgeshire
130 metres ASL
52.0N 0.1E


eastcoaster
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:51:22 AM

ECM looks mild this morning.

http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm1681.gif 

http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Recm2401.gif 

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 



LOL - first victim of the day.... ;-)

See Darren's post above! Follow the isobars and see the flow of the airmass and consider mid-winter conditions over a continental landmass under high pressure.

Originally Posted by: eastcoaster 



I was taking the p*ss.🤤
Matty H
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:51:35 AM

GFS op has lots of orange on it and is mild whether anyone likes it or not. Naturally that's trolling RollEyes

Temps into double figures for many out at T+138. ECM looks very similar.

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


I'm saying no more until the ECM ensembles come out later. Other, that is, to say that Gandalf gets it even if no-one else does!

Originally Posted by: Matty H 



Gets what? Speculation or interpretation? Or is just cold trolling? What's good for the goose... 😉

Bottom line is both charts around that stage show mild weather. Temps in southern England are up to 13c on the GFS charts.

What happens further down the line may change of course, and anyone with half a brain knows that temps will gradually fall away at ground level under sustained high pressure during winter.

The main point of interest for me is how dry it will be. Gives me an incentive to wash the car knowing it won't be plastered in grime two days later 👍

Originally Posted by: Retron 



I think you're comparing apples and oranges.....

It's the uppers in conjunction with the synoptics and GFS brings the airmass from a mild source which ECM does not.

A rare occasion when we're all right...!

If GFS is modelling the evolution correctly it may well be mild - if the High is positioned such that we get a SE component to the flow then mild it won't be (away from western coastal areas - maybe covering Yate...)

Originally Posted by: Matty H 



Which was kind of my point. You're basing your prediction on what may happen, I'm commenting on what is being shown on the GFS and ECM op charts. I haven't time to go through the spread, but there may well be options there that back your wish, so I'll give you that.

Maybe the UKMO updates will be telling later. At the moment they clearly don't "get it" either as they talk about milder weather right out to mid month as things currently stand, although the SE is mentioned as having possibly cold incursions at times.

We'll see.
SydneyonTees
Wednesday, December 4, 2013 7:55:40 AM

Hint of North African air in the models for some parts of the UK it seems, all we will need is a strong southerly and it will be more seaonsal in NSW Australia than the UK!


<There has been Christmas days here very close to UK temps when it has been exceptionally mild in the UK and exceptionally cool here>

Users browsing this topic

Remove ads from site

Ads