Remove ads from site

White Meadows
17 January 2019 14:06:09


 


The pantomime in the model output has a lot of parallels with the pantomime being played out in Parliament - no one can agree on the way forward and no-one knows how it will end.


The 06Z Op is a thing of beauty but it would cause a few problems we probably could best do without right now


Originally Posted by: RobN 

Maybe we should call it the ‘Phantomime’ 🤣


It will be strange when gfs finally gets ditched. I’ve been glaring at its charts since 2000! After years of near-hopeless upgrades finally it’s becoming obsolete.


The end of an era.

Rob K
17 January 2019 14:15:51


Maybe we should call it the ‘Phantomime’ 🤣


It will be strange when gfs finally gets ditched. I’ve been glaring at its charts since 2000! After years of near-hopeless upgrades finally it’s becoming obsolete.


The end of an era.


Originally Posted by: White Meadows 


The GFS isn't being ditched. What has always happened in the past is that the parallel simply becomes the new operational run - since 2000 there have been several.


I think this current parallel is more than simply a minor tweak, like the ones in the past - it's a more major rebuild called FV3, but AFAIK it will still be called the GFS once the transition happens.


Here's a release from 2016 about the new model.


https://www.noaa.gov/media-release/noaa-to-develop-new-global-weather-model


 


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl
"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome
Jeff
  • Jeff
  • Advanced Member
17 January 2019 14:16:05
Following my previous posts on this aspect, the US have named the storm that will govern our destiny next week. Winter Storm Harper.

Not sure if this is worthy of the Media thread but as its so key to the Model Output, here’s a link

https://weather.com/storms/winter/news/2019-01-15-winter-storm-harper-snow-forecast-plains-midwest-northeast 

Interesting in itself - 2-3 feet of snow for parts of New England. Remember, it is the storm’s ultimate depth and forward speed that has some importance to the downstream pattern

Jeff



On the East/West Sussex Border
70m ASL
Rob K
17 January 2019 14:18:13

Following my previous posts on this aspect, the US have named the storm that will govern our destiny next week. Winter Storm Harper.

Not sure if this is worthy of the Media thread but as its so key to the Model Output, here’s a link

https://weather.com/storms/winter/news/2019-01-15-winter-storm-harper-snow-forecast-plains-midwest-northeast

Interesting in itself - 2-3 feet of snow for parts of New England. Remember, it is the storm’s ultimate depth and forward speed that has some importance to the downstream pattern

Jeff


Originally Posted by: Jeff 


Can any experts shed any light on what would be better for us downstream? A sharper more explosive development, or less deepening? My instinct says the latter, as deeper cyclogenesis tends to make storms take a more northerly track, which is not what we want, right?


Yateley, NE Hampshire, 73m asl
"But who wants to be foretold the weather? It is bad enough when it comes, without our having the misery of knowing about it beforehand." — Jerome K. Jerome
Brian Gaze
17 January 2019 14:23:19


Maybe we should call it the ‘Phantomime’ 🤣


It will be strange when gfs finally gets ditched. I’ve been glaring at its charts since 2000! After years of near-hopeless upgrades finally it’s becoming obsolete.


The end of an era.


Originally Posted by: White Meadows 


What makes you think it is being ditched?


Brian Gaze
Berkhamsted
TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 
"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan
Stolen Snowman
17 January 2019 14:34:36

As I’ve read on here many times ‘get the cold in first’ which in the shorter term appears to be where we’re at.... 


To quote that other often used cliche, it’s good to see ‘a thing of beauty’ popping up now to describe some of the model output!


Statistics prove that the period just after records began witnessed some of the most extreme weather ever recorded. Records were being broken on a frequency that has not been repeated since.
Posting live from a pub somewhere in Burton upon Trent
Notty
17 January 2019 14:44:00

I wonder whether the deep cold over Europe will affect our weather soon. Will it augment any blocking weather to the East? Presumably the data fed into the models includes actual 2m temps which must be low over snow cover. Surely the deeper the cold the harder it is to shift it?


Notty
Pontypool, 132m asl
doctormog
17 January 2019 14:45:11


 


What makes you think it is being ditched?


Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 


I would assume the new FV3 version will just be renamed "GFS" when it goes live and most people will not notice the difference?


Jeff
  • Jeff
  • Advanced Member
17 January 2019 14:45:31


 


Can any experts shed any light on what would be better for us downstream? A sharper more explosive development, or less deepening? My instinct says the latter, as deeper cyclogenesis tends to make storms take a more northerly track, which is not what we want, right?


Originally Posted by: Rob K 


 


Rob, my analysis from runs which delivered and those that did not, was actually the opposite.


On those runs where the storm deepened more, it tended to slow and curve more northward, missing the jet stream like a slower, heavier surfer misses the wave and the low then dawdled near or over Greenland allowing our Atlantic high to ridge strongly northward, and keep amore mid Atlantic position allowing the previous low to drop into Europe and ...you know the rest.


ICON is persisting in keeping it a flatter, shallower, faster feature, for example.


The US forecasters are really struggling with the precipitation type forecasts because the track is so difficult. Fact is, its not even emerged over the Sierra Nevada yet were its dropping several feet of snow. 


Jeff 


 


 


 


On the East/West Sussex Border
70m ASL
Russwirral
17 January 2019 14:49:44


 


What makes you think it is being ditched?


Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 


 


Aye - think some people have misunderstood what the model rollout is.  Theres a GFSP every year isnt there?  Just seems like this year is a major roll out?  The GFSP is just the BETA version until the gremlins get ironed out.  One after UAT.


 


No different to Android or IOS updates


fairweather
17 January 2019 14:54:48

The snow row is best avoided really. For example on the whole of the chart the highest it gets for London is 22 - for today!


S.Essex, 42m ASL
Arcus
17 January 2019 14:57:03


 


Can any experts shed any light on what would be better for us downstream? A sharper more explosive development, or less deepening? My instinct says the latter, as deeper cyclogenesis tends to make storms take a more northerly track, which is not what we want, right?


Originally Posted by: Rob K 


Not an expert, but...


Ideally we're looking for a more amplified pattern upstream (anything to avoid the Azrores high folding eastward towards us and allowing that dome of warmer uppers a route east). A more NE track on that storm would encourage WAA west of Greenland and draw the Azores high north rather than toward us (which in turn aids in the displacement of the Icelandic low). There is a route to cold that doesn't demand extensive WAA (e.g. GFS 6z), but what we don't want is that storm heading out on a more southerly maritime track then heading due east.


That's my reading of it anyway...



e.g. P15 from the 6z illustrates the "worse" scenario



which gives us...



 


P01 - a "better" scenario (not a huge difference from P15, but it is different on that storm, and it's enough):





 


 


 


 


Ben,
Nr. Easingwold, North Yorkshire
30m asl
Saint Snow
17 January 2019 15:01:05


 


I would assume the new FV3 version will just be renamed "GFS" when it goes live and most people will not notice the difference?


Originally Posted by: doctormog 


 


Quite.


It'll still swing as wildly as the ballsack of a jogging buffalo.


 


 



Martin
Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)
A TWO addict since 14/12/01
"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."
Aneurin Bevan
fairweather
17 January 2019 15:06:01


 


Not an expert, but...


........ better than most !



 


 

Originally Posted by: Arcus 


S.Essex, 42m ASL
DPower
17 January 2019 15:07:55
Apparently development work on implementing the upgrade is delayed until after the shutdown. From that I would gather the para is in a kind of limbo land.
Hoping for an excellent afternoon of model watching.
Russwirral
17 January 2019 15:09:30



 


Purdy!


 


 


Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 


 


Im hoping with a bit of time us NW'ers might get a bit of blue.  Its been over 20 yrs since i last saw snow of 6"or more fall in my neck of the woods.


 


Will this be our year?


White Meadows
17 January 2019 15:16:07


 


What makes you think it is being ditched?


Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 

my misunderstanding 🖐 🤚..let’s call it model ‘evolution’ in better terms.


 

turbotubbs
17 January 2019 15:19:15


 


 


Quite.


It'll still swing as wildly as the ballsack of a jogging buffalo.


 


 


Originally Posted by: Saint Snow 

Best metaphor I've seen all week.


 

ballamar
17 January 2019 15:29:52
Think the refresh button is about to go into overdrive !!

Hopefully a continuation of trend toward blocking in the right place.
sunnyday
17 January 2019 15:34:32
Mines got auto refresh
White Meadows
17 January 2019 15:35:39
Upgrades all round in the met office mid-extended wording.
Subtle but key changes are there. Looking ace long term.

It’s starting to remind me of December 2010. Hopefully we get some good powder falls before the solar energy picks up later in Feb.
ballamar
17 January 2019 15:36:32

Mines got auto refresh

Originally Posted by: sunnyday 


 


Showoff

Heavy Weather 2013
17 January 2019 15:40:07

Extremely excited for the 12z runs. 


I must confess I was told off by a friend who reads this forum (doesn't post) that I was quick off the mark saying these runs were the most important of the winter; he said we need to see where the US storm is going first. He is quite right!


But this is a crucial set none the less. I will be looking for ICON and Para to come on board with further improvements in the ECM evolution.


Mark
Beckton, E London
Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.
Gavin D
17 January 2019 15:40:23
ICON won't be getting much of a look from coldies north westerlies eventually shifting to more of a westerly
Heavy Weather 2013
17 January 2019 15:42:53

ICON won't be getting much of a look from coldies north westerlies eventually shifting to more of a westerly

Originally Posted by: Gavin D 


That's irritating.


Mark
Beckton, E London
Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.

Remove ads from site

Ads