Remove ads from site

Brian Gaze
16 March 2020 22:19:18

It's official. The cat is out of the back. This from the BBC:




Dire prediction sees shift in UK strategy






James Gallagher


Health and science correspondent, BBC News






The UK's plan has shifted because the scientific modelling showed we were on course for a "catastrophic epidemic".


A strategy of just slowing the spread of the virus, but not trying to stop it, would have overwhelmed intensive care units.


The modelling by Imperial College London has been heavily informed by the experience in Italy and is influencing decisions at the heart of government.


Their calculations predicted 260,000 deaths in the UK.


Instead the plan is to drive down the number of cases to very low levels, which the models predict will limit deaths from coronavirus to the thousands or tens of thousands.


However, this approach comes with a major problem - there is no exit strategy.


Without the immunity that would build up if people were infected, then cases would soar as soon as measures are lifted.


The report said these could need to be in place until a vaccine is available, which could take up to 18 months.


We are in this for the long haul.


https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/world-51903319


 




Brian Gaze
Berkhamsted
TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 
"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan
Northern Sky
16 March 2020 22:21:55

Just on a potential 18 month lockdown. What happens to the millions of people who in a few months time will have had the virus and are now fit, well and immune? Are they expected to sit indoors all day still while society grinds to a halt? 

RobN
  • RobN
  • Advanced Member
16 March 2020 22:26:08


 


 Yes I will be going running in my locality. I've also got stretch bands for strength training. Was just wondering what the official line was from the government.


Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 


I would imagine the govt position is that gyms come under the "such as" clause:


Everyone should avoid gatherings and crowded places, such as pubs, clubs and theatres.


Of course if everyone else is following this guidance you might be the only one there, in which case it's fine.


Rob
In the flatlands of South Cambridgeshire 15m ASL.
Arcus
16 March 2020 22:29:06


It's official. The cat is out of the back. This from the BBC:




Dire prediction sees shift in UK strategy






James Gallagher


Health and science correspondent, BBC News






The UK's plan has shifted because the scientific modelling showed we were on course for a "catastrophic epidemic".


A strategy of just slowing the spread of the virus, but not trying to stop it, would have overwhelmed intensive care units.


The modelling by Imperial College London has been heavily informed by the experience in Italy and is influencing decisions at the heart of government.


Their calculations predicted 260,000 deaths in the UK.


Instead the plan is to drive down the number of cases to very low levels, which the models predict will limit deaths from coronavirus to the thousands or tens of thousands.


However, this approach comes with a major problem - there is no exit strategy.


Without the immunity that would build up if people were infected, then cases would soar as soon as measures are lifted.


The report said these could need to be in place until a vaccine is available, which could take up to 18 months.


We are in this for the long haul.


https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/world-51903319


 




Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 


Logical conclusion given the capacity of the healthcare system, and understandable given the data from Italy. Ideally we'd have a far lower susceptible population for the 2nd and possible 3rd waves, but we have to work around an ever-changing outlook.


Ben,
Nr. Easingwold, North Yorkshire
30m asl
The Beast from the East
16 March 2020 22:29:46


Just on a potential 18 month lockdown. What happens to the millions of people who in a few months time will have had the virus and are now fit, well and immune? Are they expected to sit indoors all day still while society grinds to a halt? 


Originally Posted by: Northern Sky 


indeed. Hopefully Boris will not criminalise people leaving the house without permission. Even if pub closes I will still go to offie or Tesco and buy cans and sit in the park with the crack heads. 


"We have some alternative facts for you"
Kelly-Ann Conway - special adviser to the President
JHutch
16 March 2020 22:30:16

Reports that the Chancellor will be in the briefing tomorrow to announce what they are going to do for businesses. 

Northern Sky
16 March 2020 22:30:34

We went out for a meal tonight to celebrate my daughters 19th. We had a delicious tapas and the dishes just kept coming. There was one other group in there and a couple. It did sort of feel like the calm of episode 2 in the final series of GOT before the dead attacked Winterfell. 


I did use anti bac gel but I've resigned myself to catching it anyway. Between working in a school and having two teenagers in the house there is almost no chance I'll avoid it. 

Northern Sky
16 March 2020 22:31:35


 


indeed. Hopefully Boris will not criminalise people leaving the house without permission. Even if pub closes I will still go to offie or Tesco and buy cans and sit in the park with the crack heads. 


Originally Posted by: The Beast from the East 


That's the spirit, good man 

John p
16 March 2020 22:36:44


We went out for a meal tonight to celebrate my daughters 19th. We had a delicious tapas and the dishes just kept coming. There was one other group in there and a couple. It did sort of feel like the calm of episode 2 in the final series of GOT before the dead attacked Winterfell. 


I did use anti bac gel but I've resigned myself to catching it anyway. Between working in a school and having two teenagers in the house there is almost no chance I'll avoid it. 


Originally Posted by: Northern Sky 


Please remember, it’s not just about you getting it - it’s about who you may pass it on to.


Camberley, Surrey
RobN
  • RobN
  • Advanced Member
16 March 2020 22:36:47

I'm dreaming that I'm living the script of a very bad movie. Hopefully I'll wake up soon and everything will be fine.


Rob
In the flatlands of South Cambridgeshire 15m ASL.
Maunder Minimum
16 March 2020 22:39:05


 


I hope the EU says no.



Originally Posted by: xioni2 


What EU? They are Donald too!


New world order coming.
JHutch
16 March 2020 22:42:29

Current estimates of the severity of cases.



John p
16 March 2020 22:43:23

Is anyone else struggling to focus on their day jobs now? Working on my IT project just seems so trivial right now, as though it will all be so irrelevant in a few months.


 I also have this overwhelming feeling of doom, the not knowing what’s around the corner (I’m still unable to get an answer as to whether I am in the high risk group (43yo, generally healthy but mild/very well controlled asthma). My wife is a teacher so it won’t be long until she catches it and passes it to me!


I do think I’ll need to limit my social media time soon for my own sanity.


Camberley, Surrey
xioni2
16 March 2020 22:44:14


We went out for a meal tonight to celebrate my daughters 19th. We had a delicious tapas and the dishes just kept coming. There was one other group in there and a couple. It did sort of feel like the calm of episode 2 in the final series of GOT before the dead attacked Winterfell. 


I did use anti bac gel but I've resigned myself to catching it anyway. Between working in a school and having two teenagers in the house there is almost no chance I'll avoid it. 


Originally Posted by: Northern Sky 


Did the anti-bac improve the taste of the tapas?


Whether Idle
16 March 2020 22:48:40


Is anyone else struggling to focus on their day jobs now? Working on my IT project just seems so trivial right now, as though it will all be so irrelevant in a few months.


 I also have this overwhelming feeling of doom, the not knowing what’s around the corner (I’m still unable to get an answer as to whether I am in the high risk group (43yo, generally healthy but mild/very well controlled asthma). My wife is a teacher so it won’t be long until she catches it and passes it to me!


I do think I’ll need to limit my social media time soon for my own sanity.


Originally Posted by: John p 


I feel now like Richard does normally


I hope he's ok, maybe its even perked him up a bit?


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
Maunder Minimum
16 March 2020 22:48:50


 


Which goes to show that, for all your pontificating about closing borders, you understand very little about the nature of this virus.


Originally Posted by: Justin W 


Look at it this way - we self isolate, we get food delivered including milk (we have milk bottles delivered daily) - you could still catch the virus if the delivery man has it, the milk bottle is contaminated and you touch your face unthinkingly after you have picked it up. It is impossible to be 100% safe from catching it.


If we had closed borders and monitored all those arriving here some weeks ago, the chance is that we could have avoided the worst - we are an island nation after all.


New world order coming.
Brian Gaze
16 March 2020 22:50:40


 


Look at it this way - we self isolate, we get food delivered including milk (we have milk bottles delivered daily) - you could still catch the virus if the delivery man has it, the milk bottle is contaminated and you touch your face unthinkingly after you have picked it up. It is impossible to be 100% safe from catching it.


 


Originally Posted by: Maunder Minimum 


On a related point we've started leaving the post and parcels for 24 hours before touching them. 


Brian Gaze
Berkhamsted
TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 
"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan
Chunky Pea
16 March 2020 22:50:40


If by the 'EU' you mean Europe, then I think they have been complacent and disorganised. I don't know if the extreme measures they are taking now will work better compared to our more cautious approach. I am surprised though that countries like Switzerland are taking so extreme measures, they are are usually very cautious and quite adverse of the federal govt imposing restrictions on the cantons.


Originally Posted by: xioni2 


Thanks, and I would generally agree.


And no, I specifically meant the EU. 


Current Conditions
https://t.ly/MEYqg 


"You don't have to know anything to have an opinion"
--Roger P, 12/Oct/2022
xioni2
16 March 2020 22:50:58


 Logical conclusion given the capacity of the healthcare system, and understandable given the data from Italy. 


Originally Posted by: Arcus 


If I use your herd immunity number and the optimistic modelled CFR, then  60% infected with a true CFR of 0.5% means ~200 thousand deaths in the UK. That 0.5% model estimate though is from China, so our NHS might yield a much higher CFR.


Are you saying that HMG has accepted that it's inevitable that hundreds of thousands of people will die during the herd immunisation process? And if yes, is this decision also shaped by economics because most of these people are pensioners and/or on benefits?


 

Chunky Pea
16 March 2020 22:55:25


 


I hope the EU says no.



Originally Posted by: xioni2 


You know.. and I know that they won't. 


Current Conditions
https://t.ly/MEYqg 


"You don't have to know anything to have an opinion"
--Roger P, 12/Oct/2022
xioni2
16 March 2020 22:56:45


 Thanks, and I would generally agree.


And no, I specifically meant the EU. 


Originally Posted by: Chunky Pea 


The problem with the EU is that it has little power/jurisdiction over national borders or the public health of member states. I am sure though the EU could have rang the alarm earlier and try to coordinate a common European response.  Had the EU asked for more powers over the member state borders and epidemics, then there would probably have been an outcry from eurosceptics.

Gandalf The White
16 March 2020 22:58:34
A professor from Imperial College on Newsnight has just said that there is precedent for a Coronavirus vaccine actually making the virus more dangerous (in one that attacks cats). It was in a brief discussion about the potential for a vaccine and how much testing is required and how long the process takes.


Location: South Cambridgeshire
130 metres ASL
52.0N 0.1E


Justin W
16 March 2020 22:58:46


 


Look at it this way - we self isolate, we get food delivered including milk (we have milk bottles delivered daily) - you could still catch the virus if the delivery man has it, the milk bottle is contaminated and you touch your face unthinkingly after you have picked it up. It is impossible to be 100% safe from catching it.


If we had closed borders and monitored all those arriving here some weeks ago, the chance is that we could have avoided the worst - we are an island nation after all.


Originally Posted by: Maunder Minimum 


Seriously? How many more f4cking times does it need to be said before it penetrates your 4” skull? 


It is not about you catching it. It is about you passing it on.


Jesus.


Yo yo yo. 148-3 to the 3 to the 6 to the 9, representing the ABQ, what up, biatch?
Maunder Minimum
16 March 2020 22:59:48


 


On a related point we've started leaving the post and parcels for 24 hours before touching them. 


Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 


Something worth thinking about.


New world order coming.
xioni2
16 March 2020 22:59:49


 Which goes to show that, for all your pontificating about closing borders, you understand very little about the nature of this virus.


Originally Posted by: Justin W 


I think you (and Brian) are right to criticise him. He spent the last 2 months here saying how serious this is and when it finally hits home, he chooses to ignore government advice, because he assesses the local risk to be zero. Perhaps he is just obsessed about borders and he only saw this crisis through that prism.


Users browsing this topic
Ads