Remove ads from site

tallyho_83
22 September 2020 13:56:42


 


CFS has very big biases (systematic errors), so at best it's only worth looking at its bias corrected forecasts. 


Originally Posted by: xioni2 


So is the purple line a new thing and I should follow that on the graph!?


Home Location - Kellands Lane, Okehampton, Devon (200m ASL)
---------------------------------------
Sean Moon
Magical Moon
www.magical-moon.com


KevBrads1
23 September 2020 07:58:30


 


Rob those CFS monthlies are top of the chocolate teapots. If you save a run of successive 6hr outputs you’ll see them wafting from hot to cold and all shapes of kitchen sink.


I looked at a weeks worth for Jan20 back in Sep last year and they ranged (for the UK) from -5 to +7 anomalies for 2m temp. If you take any seven day series for three months ahead you’ll get a fuzzy smoothed mean of around zero I reckon.


In other words, no quantitive value - not even an ‘idea’.


Originally Posted by: nsrobins 


This CFS 12z runs for next January going from 22nd September back to 16th September


 









 


What is the point of these CFS charts? They have little value, IMO, so why are they available? 


MANCHESTER SUMMER INDEX for 2021: 238
Timelapses, old weather forecasts and natural phenomena videos can be seen on this site
http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgrSD1BwFz2feWDTydhpEhQ/playlists
some faraway beach
23 September 2020 13:38:37
Well, it's good that they're available in the sense they allow us to see how thoroughly useless seasonal forecasts based on extended model runs are.

That applies equally to the ECM and GLOSEA models. It's just that the latter don't let us see the mess that goes into the final ensemble result. They just give us an unjustifiably precise final average of all these wildly differing runs.

Most of the different tools for coming up with a seasonal forecast (analogues, sunspots, hawthorn berries, QBO, etc.) have some thin strand of logic to them, which makes them worth exploring.if you have time on your hands. But model output beyond day 15, never mind week 15, is the one that definitely needs binning.
2 miles west of Taunton, 32 m asl, where "milder air moving in from the west" becomes SNOWMAGEDDON.
Well, two or three times a decade it does, anyway.
picturesareme
23 September 2020 21:46:08

If it's snow you want tally then the highest hill's of Northumberland ate forecast for snow over the weekend. Or you could head to the Highlands where again snow is on the cards for the highest hill top's.

tallyho_83
24 September 2020 00:01:47

All just for fun of course - it would happen as we head into the start of Spring!?


https://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/cfse_cartes.php?ech=3774&mode=0&carte=0&run=1


 


 


 


Home Location - Kellands Lane, Okehampton, Devon (200m ASL)
---------------------------------------
Sean Moon
Magical Moon
www.magical-moon.com


tallyho_83
24 September 2020 00:03:53

Worth a read:



https://mkweather.com/2020/07/29/first-forecast-for-winter-2020-21-early-powerful-coldwaves-nov-dec-then-weakening-of-cold-pattern-and-warm-jan-feb-mar/



If this comes about then we expect a cold and wintry start to winter before things gradually turn more mild and westerly as the QBO comes easterly along with a +AO and +NAO.


Do you know much about this long range weather forecaster/researcher Marek Kučera!?


 


Home Location - Kellands Lane, Okehampton, Devon (200m ASL)
---------------------------------------
Sean Moon
Magical Moon
www.magical-moon.com


nsrobins
24 September 2020 21:10:40


Worth a read:



https://mkweather.com/2020/07/29/first-forecast-for-winter-2020-21-early-powerful-coldwaves-nov-dec-then-weakening-of-cold-pattern-and-warm-jan-feb-mar/



If this comes about then we expect a cold and wintry start to winter before things gradually turn more mild and westerly as the QBO comes easterly along with a +AO and +NAO.


Do you know much about this long range weather forecaster/researcher Marek Kučera!?


 


Originally Posted by: tallyho_83 


That’s for the US. Apparently the opposite is expected for Europe.


Mind you, going by the grammar and spelling, long range accuracy is the least of his problems.


Neil
Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)
Stormchaser, Member TORRO
Gooner
27 September 2020 12:12:59

J F F F 


Just For Festive Fun



Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus
Banbury
North Oxfordshire
378 feet A S L


Retron
27 September 2020 12:23:05


J F F F 


Just For Festive Fun


Originally Posted by: Gooner 


50 years since the last proper White Christmas down here (albeit since then there has been snow from previous days on the ground twice, and a flake or two falling twice as well).


That chart would bring an end to the dismal run, but I won't be betting my life savings on it coming off!


Leysdown, north Kent
The Beast from the East
27 September 2020 12:25:18

The ultimate irony of being lock downed anyway during a bitter winter


"We have some alternative facts for you"
Kelly-Ann Conway - special adviser to the President
picturesareme
27 September 2020 13:34:13


 


50 years since the last proper White Christmas down here (albeit since then there has been snow from previous days on the ground twice, and a flake or two falling twice as well).


That chart would bring an end to the dismal run, but I won't be betting my life savings on it coming off!


Originally Posted by: Retron 


50 years ago there was a global flu pandemic - a rather serious one at that.

Gooner
27 September 2020 14:58:35


 


50 years since the last proper White Christmas down here (albeit since then there has been snow from previous days on the ground twice, and a flake or two falling twice as well).


That chart would bring an end to the dismal run, but I won't be betting my life savings on it coming off!


Originally Posted by: Retron 


Wonder what the odds are of a serious winter paralysing the UK forcing everyone inside thus stopping the spread of COVID?


 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus
Banbury
North Oxfordshire
378 feet A S L


Spring Sun Winter Dread
28 September 2020 14:23:27
I was thinking this too Gooner.
My gut feeling is that this could be the year we finally get a below average CET winter again perhaps with a very cold spell thrown in somewhere.
No science behind it but just a general sense that harsh winters often coincide with recessions and turmoil in the UK (1978-79, mid 1980s, 1990-91, 2008-11 period all being examples).
IIRC 2009 -10 was meant to be an apocalyptic winter of swine flu which never really materialised (cases went down and down) so there's another straw to clutch.
Sadly I think we're too far gone for a repeat with Covid...
Heavy Weather 2013
28 September 2020 18:52:23

With October on the horizon the first real chances of snow are within reach.

I think in October 2008 saw some snow in London.

I really want a cold winter this year. I’m fascinated to know how my new location may perform.


Marcus: very much looking forward to the first episode JFF.


Darren: I’m still waiting for the first proper white Christmas in my lifetime. 38 years and counting.


Mark
Beckton, E London
Less than 500m from the end of London City Airport runway.
Spring Sun Winter Dread
28 September 2020 23:01:34
Dec 2010 must have provided lying snow at least??
Plenty IMBY that year
Retron
29 September 2020 05:03:15

Dec 2010 must have provided lying snow at least??
Plenty IMBY that year

Originally Posted by: Spring Sun Winter Dread 


Not enough to count if it were an official observation, but there was a small patch left on the lawn (the thaw set in on the 21st, melting the 9cm of snow cover over two days.) There was plenty of rain and it had been mostly above freezing since then. Christmas Day 2010 was, by the narrowest of margins, an ice day here, so there was that at least.


The 1970 snowfall, incidentally, is before my time. I'm soon to be 41 and haven't seen what I consider a proper white Christmas (snow falling, snow settling on the ground) in my lifetime. I would like to see one before I die, but I'm not holding my breath!


 


Leysdown, north Kent
DEW
  • DEW
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
29 September 2020 06:22:17

Dec 2010 must have provided lying snow at least??
Plenty IMBY that year

Originally Posted by: Spring Sun Winter Dread 


A perpetual annoyance to those living south of the M4 or thereabouts is the insistence of Northerners (the North begins at Watford!) that 2010/11 was a superbly snowy year. Here on the South Coast we did indeed have a decent snowfall for once, in Dec 2010 - it lasted all of three days before thawing.


War does not determine who is right, only who is left - Bertrand Russell

Chichester 12m asl
NMA
  • NMA
  • Advanced Member
29 September 2020 06:38:05

Dec 2010 must have provided lying snow at least??
Plenty IMBY that year

Originally Posted by: Spring Sun Winter Dread 


The same here at least in this part of Dorset. For me it was the first and only time I've ever seen snow on the ground on Christmas Day several inches crisp and even too. A beautiful day with bright winter sunshine. Though if I'd put a bet on a white Christmas back then the bookies would have won as the snow has to FALL on that day apparently. But for me that was a proper white Christmas and the only one I've seen.


Vale of the Great Dairies
South Dorset
Elevation 60m 197ft
doctormog
29 September 2020 06:39:06
tallyho_83
29 September 2020 10:16:14

I was thinking this too Gooner.
My gut feeling is that this could be the year we finally get a below average CET winter again perhaps with a very cold spell thrown in somewhere.
No science behind it but just a general sense that harsh winters often coincide with recessions and turmoil in the UK (1978-79, mid 1980s, 1990-91, 2008-11 period all being examples).
IIRC 2009 -10 was meant to be an apocalyptic winter of swine flu which never really materialised (cases went down and down) so there's another straw to clutch.
Sadly I think we're too far gone for a repeat with Covid...

Originally Posted by: Spring Sun Winter Dread 


What makes you think that?


But yes a cold winter will come about eventually!? Surely!? One is well over due if not a colder than average winter month is due - surely?


Even the winter of 2017/18 was not really colder than average it was -0.2 the CET and the cold really came (as we all remember) towards the end of February.


Otherwise the winter as a whole would have been above average. Our last colder than average winter was 2008/09 2009/2010 For the exception of December 2010 the last proper colder than average winter was 2012/13. Since then we have had nothing but zonal mild westerly, damp dross!


What is conflicting is that we could be having a strong La Nina now according to the CFS model for ENSO region and we may not be going into an Easterly QBO - so this decreases our chances of a cold winter but then again the IOD is in it's negative phase, Arctic sea ice has melted to near record minimum and we are coming out of solar minimum - So this could increase our chances of a more blocked and colder winter but then we have the above caveats!? The majority of long range models show milder than average conditions throughout many parts of the northern Hemisphere this winter and I do wonder if this is a response to the strong La Nina in ENSO region? What do you think?


In July the CFS forecast the La Nina was forecast to remain weak, in August some ENS members took it down to borderline moderate LA Nina and most recently the models are showing a strong La Nina - so this goes against a cold winter!? - Same for strong El Nino. Like in 2015/16. But maybe the strength of this La Nina- beit strong if this continues could be a good thing as it will cool down the SST's in the NE Pacific which is what we all need. The Pacific ocean is warm the the SST's cooling rapidly at the ENSO region will eventually cool down other parts of the pacific like a thermostat.


We all know that recent winters we have seen huge ridge/block off south coast of Alaska and western coast of Canada develop over this warm area of SST's and this has brought brutally cold weather into Canada and N. America  - then the low pressure systems have swept eastwards across the USA and then blasted up the jet to give us persistent zonal weather/cyclogenisis or Atlantic onslaught as Gavin P would usually describe it as.      


Home Location - Kellands Lane, Okehampton, Devon (200m ASL)
---------------------------------------
Sean Moon
Magical Moon
www.magical-moon.com


RobN
  • RobN
  • Advanced Member
29 September 2020 12:30:46



Originally Posted by: doctormog 


The Met Office are having a laugh with this chart.


I do recall that in Dec 2010 many people were raving about what a wintry month it was it but in my location ( Cam valley in South Cambridgeshire) I recall it as being virtually snowless.


On days when there is snow falling or snow lying I normally make a point of getting outside and taking a photo of it.


From that month I have photos of snow lying on just two days.


12 to 16 days? No chance!


 


Rob
In the flatlands of South Cambridgeshire 15m ASL.
Chelsea
29 September 2020 13:48:49

[quote=Retron;1260271]


 


Not enough to count if it were an official observation, but there was a small patch left on the lawn (the thaw set in on the 21st, melting the 9cm of snow cover over two days.) There was plenty of rain and it had been mostly above freezing since then. Christmas Day 2010 was, by the narrowest of margins, an ice day here, so there was that at least.


The 1970 snowfall, incidentally, is before my time. I'm soon to be 41 and haven't seen what I consider a proper white Christmas (snow falling, snow settling on the ground) in my lifetime. I would like to see one before I die, but I'm not holding my breath!


 


I lived in Sittingbourne and remember the snow of 1970 very well. I am an old git of 65. If I remember it started Christmas eve

Saint Snow
29 September 2020 14:19:14


 


A perpetual annoyance to those living south of the M4 or thereabouts is the insistence of Northerners (the North begins at Watford!) that 2010/11 was a superbly snowy year. Here on the South Coast we did indeed have a decent snowfall for once, in Dec 2010 - it lasted all of three days before thawing.


Originally Posted by: DEW 


 


Seems a hit & miss thing, DEW. The post after yours describes their Dorset back yard that year as having a Xmas Day with "several inches crisp and even too"


 


I'm a tad north of Watford and that December was a fraught time because areas to the north, south, east and west of us had got snow, often very deep snow, during the cold spell, but we had been bone dry (a couple of times a front or feature was showing on the MO up until 48 hours away, then would disappear or divert away). When the MO began to show a weak front moving toward us from the W/NW for around the 17th, I watched with expectation of disappointment, but it firmed up and by the morning of 17th, we were forecast 1-2cm. I'd have been happy with that (we had about 10cm of lying snow the previous Xmas, too!) after the disappointment up until then. But it was a better fall, and lasted beyond Xmas.



Martin
Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)
A TWO addict since 14/12/01
"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."
Aneurin Bevan
Saint Snow
29 September 2020 14:35:48


 


Not enough to count if it were an official observation, but there was a small patch left on the lawn (the thaw set in on the 21st, melting the 9cm of snow cover over two days.) There was plenty of rain and it had been mostly above freezing since then. Christmas Day 2010 was, by the narrowest of margins, an ice day here, so there was that at least.


The 1970 snowfall, incidentally, is before my time. I'm soon to be 41 and haven't seen what I consider a proper white Christmas (snow falling, snow settling on the ground) in my lifetime. I would like to see one before I die, but I'm not holding my breath!


 


Originally Posted by: Retron 


 


Was born in 1972 so also missed Dec 70. I do remember the snow on the ground in Dec 81, but I don't think it snowed on the actual day. There was a year in the mid-/late-90's when it snowed in the early hours of Xmas Day morning. Went to bed clear; woke up with about half a cm covering, which had froze; clear deep blue sky, too. Wondrous.


Dec 2004 saw frequent heavy showers of graupel and flake, putting down about 3cm (that froze, too). Dec 09 had snow on the ground from a lot of showers that started the weekend before and continued through the week, snow-on-snow! Was about 10cm by Xmas Day and I think we got a few flurries on the day itself. In Dec 10 we had deep snow lying but none fell. We also had an unexpected Boxing Day fall in 2014 that was heavy for a time before turning to rain.


Not done too bad - but we never seem to get the mega-falls at any time. Don't think we've ever reached 30cm level snow in my 48 years, whereas you can relate your tale of helicopter food-drops and snow as deep as the hedges.



Martin
Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)
A TWO addict since 14/12/01
"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."
Aneurin Bevan
Gooner
29 September 2020 14:49:38


With October on the horizon the first real chances of snow are within reach.

I think in October 2008 saw some snow in London.

I really want a cold winter this year. I’m fascinated to know how my new location may perform.


Marcus: very much looking forward to the first episode JFF.


Darren: I’m still waiting for the first proper white Christmas in my lifetime. 38 years and counting.


Originally Posted by: Heavy Weather 2013 


I'm with you Mark , I know I haven't made enough of heavy snowfall in recent years and yes a white Xmas would be great for all 


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus
Banbury
North Oxfordshire
378 feet A S L


Remove ads from site

Ads