Remove ads from site

nickl
28 December 2013 15:20:31
Gentlemen, the meto update states late in January. That can have nothing to do with ECM (either extended or 32 dayer cos that isn't wintry), or mogreps-15. It can only be their strat model predicting a sig warming post mid month and a the possibility of a quick response downwelling into the trop. that is a fairly tenuous probablity
Gooner
28 December 2013 15:26:55









Aye, but there is no Arctic high moving down over Scandinavia and no sign of the continent cooling.  So might just as well be looking for dull greyness from Spain!

(why people like dull grey weather in winter beats me, but there you go!)


Originally Posted by: Essan 


That's making rather a lot of assumptions! Suffice to say that none of us can tell what sort of easterly we'd get, there have been all sorts on offer in the ensembles from a quick easterly waft to proper deep cold easterlies (even in the 6z GEFS today, if you have a browse!)


I'd rather take a grey, tepid easterly recycled from the Med any day over the recent gales and rain.


(Besides, although it was a few weeks ago now, before this zonal spell we had a Euro high with SSE'lies. It led to the only frosts of the winter so far down here, combined with crisp, sunny days. And that was from a "warm" source!)


 


Originally Posted by: Gooner 


Me too


Even the latest update mention the possibility of significant cold later in Jan......................Easteerly?


Originally Posted by: Essan 




Northerly? 


Originally Posted by: Gooner 


I doubt it , that would be a fleeting shot of cold and significantly?? Not too sure


Originally Posted by: Essan 



But why would an easterly bring 'significant cold' to 95% of the UK?    

Though has to be asked what the MetO means by that - overnight temps below zero would be significantly colder than anything we've had so far this winter!  

Anyway, despite one outlier at T+384 there's nothing to suggest an easterly at this stage - and certainly nothing to suggest one bringing significantly cold weather to Britain.  



Originally Posted by: Gooner 


Where did the % come from ??

Originally Posted by: Retron 



Okay, too be fair I'm not sure that even the SE corner of Kent gets 'significant cold' from an easterly these days


Not too sure the Met update is based on GFS are you   

Originally Posted by: Essan 



I'm very sure it's not!  

But I'm also unaware of any reason why the reference to a possibility of temps turning significantly colder than the current mildness in mid Jan must refer to an easterly?   It's not even a straw, it's a few molecules of dung that was made by a horse that once ate straw for breakfast ....

And anyway, I really don't get this obsession people have with the fluffy pink bunny!   I prefer cold, frosty, snowy weather in winter!



6c here so significantly colder would take itdown to 1 or 2c IMO


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus
Banbury
North Oxfordshire
378 feet A S L


Retron
28 December 2013 15:28:27

Gentlemen, the meto update states late in January. That can have nothing to do with ECM (either extended or 32 dayer cos that isn't wintry), or mogreps-15. It can only be their strat model predicting a sig warming post mid month and a the possibility of a quick response downwelling into the trop. that is a fairly tenuous probablity

Originally Posted by: nickl 


December 28 + 32 days = 29th January. That's "late in January", is it not?


The text forecasts on the Met Office site use a mix of MOGREPS-15, ECM-15, ECM-32 and DECIDER (which is a way of clustering the 32-day and 15-day ensemble output).


I assume you have full access to ECM-32 then to say with certainty it doesn't show any wintriness? Thought not!


It's important to note that cold, blocked scenarios are of course very much in the minority at the moment - but there's enough of them for the MetO to mention it as a possibility. That's really all there is to it at the moment!


 


Leysdown, north Kent
Essan
28 December 2013 15:38:18



But why would an easterly bring 'significant cold' to 95% of the UK?    


Originally Posted by: Retron 


I'm sure you know how an easterly could bring 'significant cold'. If for some reason you can't, check out the control, or failing that perturbations 2, 5 or 18 from the 6z.




Anyway, despite one outlier at T+384 there's nothing to suggest an easterly at this stage - and certainly nothing to suggest one bringing significantly cold weather to Britain.  

Originally Posted by: Essan 


I've no idea what charts you're looking at, but they're clearly not the same ones I'm looking at - or the Met Office, come to that. There is a small but notable risk of an easterly type developing as can clearly be seen from the past couple of days' worth of model output. And that includes the bits you have to pay to see (such as the ECM-15 control run) and those bits you can't buy access to (such as MOGREPS-15).


 


Okay, fair enough you look at stuff us mere mortals can't see.

But the point is: how can you be so certain that an easterly is the only possible reason for MetO thinking there is a chance it might turn a bit colder later in January    And how can you be certain that even if all the models pointed to this happening in 25 days time, that they are right?   Because they always are at that range? 


Andy
Evesham, Worcs, Albion - 35m asl
Weather & Earth Science News 

Anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job - DNA
nickl
28 December 2013 15:38:41

Gentlemen, the meto update states late in January. That can have nothing to do with ECM (either extended or 32 dayer cos that isn't wintry), or mogreps-15. It can only be their strat model predicting a sig warming post mid month and a the possibility of a quick response downwelling into the trop. that is a fairly tenuous probablity

Originally Posted by: Retron 


December 28 + 32 days = 29th January. That's "late in January", is it not?


The text forecasts on the Met Office site use a mix of MOGREPS-15, ECM-15, ECM-32 and DECIDER (which is a way of clustering the 32-day and 15-day ensemble output).


I assume you have full access to ECM-32 then to say with certainty it doesn't show any wintriness? Thought not!


It's important to note that cold, blocked scenarios are of course very much in the minority at the moment - but there's enough of them for the MetO to mention it as a possibility. That's really all there is to it at the moment!


 

Originally Posted by: nickl 



I've seen the 51 member ens run and it ain't wintry. Of course there could be some cold members in there but if so, why not mention the possibilities yesterday?
Retron
28 December 2013 15:52:13


Okay, fair enough you look at stuff us mere mortals can't see.


Originally Posted by: Essan 


I'm a mere mortal myself. I just happen to go out there and get as much info as I can, rather than just relying on what others say, or what charts are easily available.


I have a free trial to Accuweather Pro which has some - but by no means all, or even most - of the ECM-32 output. Anyone with a credit card can sign up for the free trial - it's well worth doing if, like me, you want access to as much as you can. You can also get free access to Glasgow ECM-32 data from here.




But the point is: how can you be so certain that an easterly is the only possible reason for MetO thinking there is a chance it might turn a bit colder later in January    And how can you be certain that even if all the models pointed to this happening in 25 days time, that they are right?   Because they always are at that range? 



Easy, I've been reading what Ian's been posting and looking at the ECM-32 and ECM-15 data that I have access to each day. You can get access to it too and NW is only a click or two away - it's not some magic source, it's available to everyone.


If you read my posts rather than making more assumptions(!) you'd see that your second question is completely irrelevant, as I've never said nor implied that.


Leysdown, north Kent
Retron
28 December 2013 15:56:28


I've seen the 51 member ens run and it ain't wintry. Of course there could be some cold members in there but if so, why not mention the possibilities yesterday?

Originally Posted by: nickl 


The full run, yes? As in out to T+768? In which case, you'll have seen that there are some colder members in there. Not many, but enough to be worth a mention (as per yesterday). If you have access to ECM-15 you'll note that there are slightly more colder runs by day 15 than there were yesterday, hence the change in emphasis.


The Met Office just report based on what their ensembles (that's ECM-15, ECM-32 and MOGREPS-15) are saying. If they've changed the wording on cold when ECM-32 hasn't updated, then all it means is that ECM-15 and/or MOGREPS-15 have changed a bit since the previous forecast.


Leysdown, north Kent
Hungry Tiger
28 December 2013 15:56:50

Please chaps - keep on topic.



Gavin S. FRmetS.
TWO Moderator.
Contact the TWO team - [email protected]
South Cambridgeshire. 93 metres or 302.25 feet ASL.


Retron
28 December 2013 16:10:56


Please chaps - keep on topic.



Originally Posted by: Hungry Tiger 


Eh? This is on topic - we're discussing what the ensembles show and, in the face of those who are unaware of what's out there, pointing to sites which contain the ECM ensembles that we all want to see.


In fact, I might as well post some links all in one post so that people can see what's out there and make their own minds up - it's always the best way, rather than just relying on second-hand info.


As it stands, there is a small but noteworthy chance of a colder change by mid-Jan. The ECM-15 has been showing a cold cluster for a few runs now and ECM-32 has several cold runs in it too. The current 0z ECM-15 has a control run which shows an easterly developing by day 15, whereas Thursday's ECM-32 had a control run which just showed zonality out to day 32. This mirrors what we're seeing in GEFS, too, with a small number of runs showing a switch to a colder solution. Both GEFS and ECM-15 show SW'lies being the dominant wind direction but between 10 and 15% of GEFS and ECM-15 runs show an easterly developing.


Or, in short - unsettled conditions are still the most likely outcome for the next two weeks BUT there's also a 10-15% chance of a switch to much colder conditions. It's been that way for a couple of days and I'm sure most on here will be keeping an eye on the models to see whether that probability increases over the next few days.


And so, onto the links for those who were unware - please bookmark these and use them!


MOGREPS-15 - Days 1 to 5 - Met Office (enter a location, then click Temp Range)


Days 6 to 10 - BBC Weather (enter a postcode, then click the next 5 days link)


ECM-15 - London ensembles (temperature, wind, rain)


SW Netherlands ensembles (temperature, rain, dewpoint, cloud cover, wind direction and strength)


De Bilt ensembles (temperature, rain, snow, wind)


Days 6 - 10 Ensemble mean charts


Days 6 - 10 Ensemble spread charts


(Pay site with 1 week free trial) ensemble mean charts


(Pay site with 1 month free trial) ensemble control charts


ECM-32 - Glasgow ensembles (temperature, rain)


(Pay site with 1 month free trial) ensemble control charts


Weatherbell may have ECM-32 data as well, but it was unavailable during my free trial.


It's worth checking ECMWF's website too. They sometimes offer the 15-day Reading ensembles or 5-day ECM-15 postage stamps. (Click the thumbnail top left of the homepage)


 


 


Leysdown, north Kent
some faraway beach
28 December 2013 16:28:58


Please chaps - keep on topic.



Originally Posted by: Hungry Tiger 


 What the ...!?


 


I've just been reading the most on-topic couple of pages of discussion ever on the Model Output thread.


Thanks to everyone for helping nail down what can justifiably and plausibly be extracted by us amateurs from long-range model outputs.


2 miles west of Taunton, 32 m asl, where "milder air moving in from the west" becomes SNOWMAGEDDON.
Well, two or three times a decade it does, anyway.
Essan
28 December 2013 16:49:42



Okay, fair enough you look at stuff us mere mortals can't see.


Originally Posted by: Retron 


I'm a mere mortal myself. I just happen to go out there and get as much info as I can, rather than just relying on what others say, or what charts are easily available.


I have a free trial to Accuweather Pro which has some - but by no means all, or even most - of the ECM-32 output. Anyone with a credit card can sign up for the free trial - it's well worth doing if, like me, you want access to as much as you can. You can also get free access to Glasgow ECM-32 data from here.




But the point is: how can you be so certain that an easterly is the only possible reason for MetO thinking there is a chance it might turn a bit colder later in January    And how can you be certain that even if all the models pointed to this happening in 25 days time, that they are right?   Because they always are at that range? 


Originally Posted by: Essan 


Easy, I've been reading what Ian's been posting and looking at the ECM-32 and ECM-15 data that I have access to each day. You can get access to it too and NW is only a click or two away - it's not some magic source, it's available to everyone.


If you read my posts rather than making more assumptions(!) you'd see that your second question is completely irrelevant, as I've never said nor implied that.





The assumptions being made here are that what a few runs at very extreme FI range show is likely to happen - and that those questioning this are wrong  

(It may happen,we may even get the fabled beasterly, but at this stage there is nothing in model output to say that it will happen - and a run of northerlies, or even increasingly cold northwestelies - are just as likely IMO)


Worth noting that after a mild December and with model output showing nothing particularly cold at this stage for early January, the chances are that late Jan or Feb could well see colder weather than we've seen so far this winter (it being traditionally the coldest period of the year).   That's stating the obvious without needing to look at any model output! 


Andy
Evesham, Worcs, Albion - 35m asl
Weather & Earth Science News 

Anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job - DNA
JACKO4EVER
28 December 2013 16:53:21


Please chaps - keep on topic.



Originally Posted by: some faraway beach 


 What the ...!?


 


I've just been reading the most on-topic couple of pages of discussion ever on the Model Output thread.


Thanks to everyone for helping nail down what can justifiably and plausibly be extracted by us amateurs from long-range model outputs.

Originally Posted by: Hungry Tiger 


I am sure Gavin was referring to us reverting to the usual straw clutching, hot air tripe of previous threads! LOL
Good read folks, there is a small chance of cold conditions developing, but then again there's also a small chance of the earth being hit by a comet of monsterous proportions rendering all meteorological forecasts useless anyways!
Reasonably mild and wet sums it up for me, and until we see something different approach reasonable timeframes then that's how it stays

nsrobins
28 December 2013 17:10:27



Please chaps - keep on topic.



Originally Posted by: some faraway beach 


 What the ...!?


 


I've just been reading the most on-topic couple of pages of discussion ever on the Model Output thread.


Thanks to everyone for helping nail down what can justifiably and plausibly be extracted by us amateurs from long-range model outputs.


Originally Posted by: Hungry Tiger 


I have to agree. And thanks for the links, Darren.


Neil
Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)
Stormchaser, Member TORRO
KevBrads1
28 December 2013 17:12:56

Don't look at CFS extended if it's cold your looking for- could well be a very wet and reasonably mild winter if that's anything to go by. On other current output, I believe the wet and mobile weather is here until at least mid January.
Flooding will become a problem no doubt

Originally Posted by: JACKO4EVER 




Don't look at extended CFS FULL STOP.

I am convinced CFS stands for complete fanatsy scenarios.

MANCHESTER SUMMER INDEX for 2021: 238
Timelapses, old weather forecasts and natural phenomena videos can be seen on this site
http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgrSD1BwFz2feWDTydhpEhQ/playlists
Retron
28 December 2013 17:19:03


The assumptions being made here are that what a few runs at very extreme FI range show is likely to happen

Originally Posted by: Essan 


I've made it clear time and time again that the easterly option is only a small chance and backed up my statement with links, model info and analysis. Nobody else seems to have been expecting it to happen either, so I really don't know where you're going with this one. I'll leave you to it, I think, as you have your own views which are different to what the models are actually showing.


Meanwhile the 12z GEFS is rolling out - to 180 as of writing this - and the thing that strikes me most is the upper low forecast to be over or very near the UK in around half of the runs. Not good news generally, as it would mean further deluges and widespread gales. It's a notable change from the 6z ensembles, which only had around a third showing a deep upper low over or near the UK, the majority showed a more zonal upper flow.


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gefs_cartes.php?ech=180&code=0&mode=0&carte=


I would expect an easterly or two in the extended ensembles, continuing the trend from the past couple of days (the trend being to have a small chance of an easterly, not a trend towards increasing the chance of an easterly).


Leysdown, north Kent
Gooner
28 December 2013 17:37:46

http://modeles.meteociel.fr/modeles/gens/run/gensnh-0-1-300.png?12


The Block to the East is always lurking


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus
Banbury
North Oxfordshire
378 feet A S L


Jiries
28 December 2013 18:03:13



The assumptions being made here are that what a few runs at very extreme FI range show is likely to happen

Originally Posted by: Retron 


I've made it clear time and time again that the easterly option is only a small chance and backed up my statement with links, model info and analysis. Nobody else seems to have been expecting it to happen either, so I really don't know where you're going with this one. I'll leave you to it, I think, as you have your own views which are different to what the models are actually showing.


Meanwhile the 12z GEFS is rolling out - to 180 as of writing this - and the thing that strikes me most is the upper low forecast to be over or very near the UK in around half of the runs. Not good news generally, as it would mean further deluges and widespread gales. It's a notable change from the 6z ensembles, which only had around a third showing a deep upper low over or near the UK, the majority showed a more zonal upper flow.


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gefs_cartes.php?ech=180&code=0&mode=0&carte=


I would expect an easterly or two in the extended ensembles, continuing the trend from the past couple of days (the trend being to have a small chance of an easterly, not a trend towards increasing the chance of an easterly).


Originally Posted by: Essan 


Absolutely straight westeries after 108 with direct flow from N America and looking at 850's uppers the very cold pooling just died out before reaching Ireland, it doesn't become very cold again if enter landfall since Ireland and UK doesn't develop own cold pooling.  I am sure many flights from N America would take this flow to reach Europe much faster while flights going there have to go north then turn west sharply to follow the northern flank of the LP.  I watched that on my wife's flight path on 23rd Dec which took very north to Scotland then toward Greenland then sharp turn SW ward as it following the LP northern flow which arrived to batter the UK overnight.

Nordic Snowman
28 December 2013 18:14:27

Agree with Kevin re: CFS. Picking out trends can be difficult but CFS is awful imho.


http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/MT8_London_ens.png


An unsettled picture throughout but a few tentative and continuing signs of a change mid month. Looks like ample rainfall for London which can only mean the more prone areas to the W and N are in for a soaking. A definate trend for cooler weather and so some wintry ppn at times on the higher ground and no doubt, some transitional sleet/wet snow at lower levels within that mess.


Bjorli, Norway

Website 
LA2B MeridFlowEuro09
28 December 2013 18:31:18

Yes ok please No Not a Surprise!.

Taken a balanced view of GFS 12z and the UKMO 12z runs, we look SET for a lot of heavy rain and strong winds associated with the Wide spread N Atlantic and UK PV mass area of Low Pressure, yes there is a few pockets of Milder wedges, but Equally there is Colder Temps bot at 500hPa and the T850hPa levels and that bring cold temps at the surface as well as higher up.

That means there is a good mix of Snow or Rain and some Hail and Sleet in the next 7 days.

Best Wishes for the New Year to all.

NB this Strat warming Episode is in full swing and it appears that the Scandy High is in the picture and inside GFS - Blocking High for W Europe spreads from Scandy in about 10 days time - next Friday and Saturday cold and Wintry active NW airflow, a ridge following Sunday after that, then a 4 day period of WSW to ENE across N Atlantic from Centre and Through the UK, in the Week after it- with a few mild sectors, then A PV Split with Deep mid to far NW Central n Atlantic Low P, and a Deep PV low heads across N and NE of Azores Isles, so it could help high pressure over Scandy to link to Developing UK Anticyclone and make a Cold Block high across N W and mid to NE Europe, while a Deep low from Iceland later could head to Norwegian Sea and to our Arctic Sea NE of UK in Norwegian Sea far NE Atlantic.

This may be at 11-13 Jan timeframe, and a Cold vs Mild area could form over Cemtral N USA and E NE USA as High pressure blocking forms West and North and PV low's move West and NW from the Central N Atlantic to into Newfounfland and the WAA form there right Low P also to SW Greenland around that time.

The Arctic Cold Pool will inflate as the High pressure builds up over Icelqnd and the UK- we could bring Northerly winds down from our North towards Week 2 and 3 of January 2013- Southerly Tracking low's to Britain from Svalbard and OR Denmark Netherlands with both cold air flow from North and the East is qiute possible, having a chance of Deflecting the Atlantic Low Pressure belt to Spain and the Meditteranean.
Climate is warming up, Scotland and N Ireland and North England still often gets some Winter frost, ice and snow, November to March, but the SE and South UK including S Central England and Wales, together with the West and North through the year, they sometimes get more rain than London and S SE England, where some longer dry fine spells without much heavy rain is seen every year.

The North Atlantic Sea often gets some much Colder Wintry conditions from November to March Months, and Mild SW and South winds tend to be more frequent over the East and SE of North Atlantic Sea, as the Azores High tends to stay in charge. 

With this warmth and heat, the Central and South UK has become mostly free of snow and frost.
Gooner
28 December 2013 18:44:00

http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/ecmwf/runs/2013122812/ECH1-192.GIF?28-0


High Pressure to the East looks much stronger, probably wont get there this time but at least it is being picked up


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus
Banbury
North Oxfordshire
378 feet A S L


Whether Idle
28 December 2013 19:00:03




Please chaps - keep on topic.



Originally Posted by: nsrobins 


 What the ...!?


 


I've just been reading the most on-topic couple of pages of discussion ever on the Model Output thread.


Thanks to everyone for helping nail down what can justifiably and plausibly be extracted by us amateurs from long-range model outputs.


Originally Posted by: some faraway beach 


I have to agree. And thanks for the links, Darren.


Originally Posted by: Hungry Tiger 


A fascinating debate.  Thanks to Darren and Andy for their sparring.  Classic TWO M.O.D.


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
Quantum
28 December 2013 19:18:45

Still nothing for a while at least. So much for the coldest and snowiest winter in 700 years.... 


Twitter: @QuantumOverlord (general), @MedicaneWatch (medicane/TC stuff)
2023/2024 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):
29/11 (-6), 30/11 (-6), 02/12 (-5), 03/12 (-5), 04/12 (-3), 16/01 (-3), 18/01 (-8), 08/02 (-5)

Total: 8 days with snow/sleet falling.

2022/2023 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):

18/12 (-1), 06/03 (-6), 08/03 (-8), 09/03 (-6), 10/03 (-8), 11/03 (-5), 14/03 (-6)

Total: 7 days with snow/sleet falling.

2021/2022 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):

26/11 (-5), 27/11 (-7), 28/11 (-6), 02/12 (-6), 06/01 (-5), 07/01 (-6), 06/02 (-5), 19/02 (-5), 24/02 (-7), 30/03 (-7), 31/03 (-8), 01/04 (-8)
Total: 12 days with snow/sleet falling.
Scandy 1050 MB
28 December 2013 19:45:04


Still nothing for a while at least. So much for the coldest and snowiest winter in 700 years.... 


Originally Posted by: Quantum 


Looking at the available data late January into February may be the best option (hope!) of anything cold at the moment - as in Gavin's excellent video with the stratosphere so abnormally cold there's no end in sight to the strong jet. Perhaps a sudden warming event may come to our rescue but I am looking to February realistcally lookng at the current output, especially as no SSW event is predicted at the moment.


Too early to call it a mild winter but if nothing changes it may well end up being a  retro 90's winter!

Quantum
28 December 2013 20:02:35



Still nothing for a while at least. So much for the coldest and snowiest winter in 700 years.... 


Originally Posted by: Scandy 1050 MB 


Looking at the available data late January into February may be the best option (hope!) of anything cold at the moment - as in Gavin's excellent video with the stratosphere so abnormally cold there's no end in sight to the strong jet. Perhaps a sudden warming event may come to our rescue but I am looking to February realistcally lookng at the current output, especially as no SSW event is predicted at the moment.


Too early to call it a mild winter but if nothing changes it may well end up being a  retro 90's winter!


Originally Posted by: Quantum 


Yes I agree, do you think its too early to call a mild (or at least not below average) january though? For there to be enough time to give us a cold spell by late january, we really would have to see a SSW event appearing on the models soon (for there to be a caustive link between the two ofc). Perhaps that HP over newfoundland in FI might bring some more interesting model watching, it might help to warm things up a bit and stop the rampaging cyclogenesis. 


Twitter: @QuantumOverlord (general), @MedicaneWatch (medicane/TC stuff)
2023/2024 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):
29/11 (-6), 30/11 (-6), 02/12 (-5), 03/12 (-5), 04/12 (-3), 16/01 (-3), 18/01 (-8), 08/02 (-5)

Total: 8 days with snow/sleet falling.

2022/2023 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):

18/12 (-1), 06/03 (-6), 08/03 (-8), 09/03 (-6), 10/03 (-8), 11/03 (-5), 14/03 (-6)

Total: 7 days with snow/sleet falling.

2021/2022 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):

26/11 (-5), 27/11 (-7), 28/11 (-6), 02/12 (-6), 06/01 (-5), 07/01 (-6), 06/02 (-5), 19/02 (-5), 24/02 (-7), 30/03 (-7), 31/03 (-8), 01/04 (-8)
Total: 12 days with snow/sleet falling.
Users browsing this topic

    Remove ads from site

    Ads