Gerrard doesn't play a simple DM role at Liverpool. He sits behind two high-energy midfielders, who do a lot of the DM work, just a bit higher up the pitch. Gerrard acts more as a sweeper/'quarterback'. Liverpool have tried playing Henderson as a straight DM, but it didn't really work. Under Hodgson's set-up, he played both Gerrard & Henderson deeper, with the midfielders (Welbeck, Rooney, Sterling) a bit further up. The result was that Gerrard & Henderson had too much ground/too many opposition midfielders to cover. Both looked well below their Liverpool performance levels in each game.
The tactic in the Italy game to put Sterling in a central role up against Pirlo had merit in theory. Not only will Sterling put in a stint when we don't have the ball (and can be a niggley player), but his movement & pace on the ball would occupy Pirlo, hopefully tiring him to nullify his attacking prowess. It didn't work. Pirlo just found space away from Sterling (and neither Rooney nor Welbeck really picked him up enough), whilst he just let a teammate do the defensive work on Sterling.
Hodgson's been unlucky in having the worst England back 4 I can remember. Cahill looked good in terms of defensive duties (from a 'all-hands-to-the-pumps-never-say-die perspective), but he was pants on the ball and often gave the ball right back to the opposition. But Jagielka, Baines and Johnson were poor against Italy and, for the beginning of each half, had nightmares against Uruguay, who gave them absolutely no time on the ball.
I thought Lallana helped change the game when he came on - he looks so comfortable on the ball. Of course, Uruguay's pressing wasn't as rabid by this time, but he did well. His introduction also seemed to coincide with Baines looking much better, too.
Overall scores out of 10 for the team last night (scores for the Italy game in brackets):
Hart - 6 (6)
Johnson - 6 (4)
Jagielka - 5 (5)
Cahill - 6.5 (5.5)
Baines - 5 (4.5)
Gerrard - 5 (5.5)
Henderson - 5.5 (5)
Sterling - 5.5 (8)
Rooney - 6.5 (5)
Welbeck - 4 (5.5)
Originally Posted by: Saint Snow