Remove ads from site

Fothergill
25 December 2015 19:52:06



Wow, some very interesting charts lately. That ECM could turn into a corker of a run if it went further. But these charts are at least 10 days away, how many times have we been here before. Probably only about 1 in 10 significant easterlies that the models toy with in FI ever comes off, if that. My feeling is that we will end up in somewhere in the middle with the Atlantic influence too dominant but we'll see. Could be a very nice surprise though after the god-awful charts so far.


 

Ally Pally Snowman
25 December 2015 19:52:41


Wasn't it GEM that first came up with the idea of an Easterly???


Below are a few comments from several days back


The models remain very poor, I doubt if deep down anyone really expects a change from this mild regime for the rest of the winter. 


From Shropshire ....Dec 17th


 


You could be on to something Mr Moomin, although it wouldn't surprise me to see the change just after Christmas. Too early to say but there does seem to be more evidence of a pattern change than has been the case in the last few days. It will be interesting to see what the charts show for the post Christmas period in a couple of days.


From Doc  18th Dec .............Very sensible


 





If we want what the ECM shows to happen then it just shows how bad the position is.


What happened to the warming event that people were talking about for esrly January, doesn't seem to be on according to the other side, I've noticed Steve Murr and the Jam Tamara woman don't seem to be on there anymore.


 From the vanishing Shropshire Dec 18th


 


Its a good chart but we've been here before with Ecm day 10 charts. We're still 2 or 3 weeks away from any serious cold at least all the ensembles at the moment are shocking.


 


 From Ally Pally Dec  18th .......whoops


 


Steve Ive been watching the WAA for that S-N orientation.  It simply hasn't even been modelled right let alone happened.  Its always as you say been SW-NE which simply locks us into THE MILDNESS.


To get S-N oriented WAA at this you need a wall of high pressure all the way up into the Arctic to our east.  Without this very rare occurrence the WAA from the deep TM air masses is simply wasted.


It is definitely a case of making the most of what you've got and until something changes dramatically upstream, the only way out to cold is the S-N WAA scenario with a hoped for compensatory plunge south of frigid air.


Its all such a long way off. 1% hope.


From Weather Idle  Dec 18th .........1% eh ?


 


any cold in FI is just that, fantasy, just noise.


white noise.


From Stone Cold ........no surprise Dec 19th


 


Yes, a Paul Simon song springs to mind but we shall see. The problem is the whole process could take several weeks.


From Brian Gaze  Dec 19th.......just shows you can't go on past experiences


 


I feel the models, especially the ECM, are suggesting a post Christmad pattern change


From Doc again......Dec19th


And Ally Pally's reply to the above


The ensembles just don't suggest this at the moment though neither ecm or GFS. Looks mild beyond new year to me .


 


We will have to wait until February at the earliest


From Maunder Dec 19th


 


With these forecasted blocks to the East, 9 times out of ten in my experience it gets pushed away and flattened by the jet back into a Euro high, giving us another sustained spell of Atlantic westerlies. To me it looks like this is what's going to happen this time, especially as the jet looks strong .


From Fothergill  Dec 19th


 


Never say never, but I think the more "seasoned " campaigners can see where this one is likely to be headed


 From Weather Idle  Dec 19th ..................of course WI means though who thought cold was around the corner ......lol....................not


 


As for early Jan it looks quite unsettled based on the GEFS. Despite what some people say on the forums, I seriously doubt whether MOGREPS and the European ensembles show a significantly different picture to GEFS except on very rare occasions


From Brian Gaze 20th Dec


 


I'm not saying a raging Easterly is likely but even some of 'The big boys' were thinking cold is weeks and weeks away , yet 7 days or so later we have an Easterly showing up on several models.  It  doesn't really matter what experience you have you can never outbox the weather .


 


Interesting times.............................hopefully


 





 


Originally Posted by: Gooner 


To be fair my comment on the 18th about still being 2 to 3 weeks away from any serious cold would be bang on if the ECM is correct tonight. The ensembles were crap at the time hopefully the ECM is onto something tonight.


 


 


 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
picturesareme
25 December 2015 19:54:50

Hmm I just can't shift the feelinh this place is going to be suicidal hot pot in the coming days... #imstillnotbuyintoit 

ITSY
25 December 2015 20:02:54

Even if doesn't come off, this is the kind of excitement that we enjoy - great to have it emerging around Christmas. 


Anyone know when the ensembles come out for ECM? And the GFSP? Should be interesting. 


Happy xmas all, enjoy the family fallouts from articulate


fingers crossed for a new year change of fortunes in the weather! 

springsunshine
25 December 2015 20:06:56

Despite all the hype about a major pattern change our immediate attention should be concentrated on the coming week/rest of 2015.


The forecast for Cumbria/northern England and southern Scotland for tomorrow is very wet again,they need more heavy rain like a hole in the head! Our thoughts must go out to them and best wishes and fingers crossed for members in that part of the world.The risk of more severe flooding has been taken very seriously by the authorities and measures put in place to try and limit further flood damage.Good luck to all up there our thoughts are with you.


Tuesday night and Wednesday look horrific for the whole of the uk as does new years eve,one brutal atlantic storm after another.Continuing very mild with temps 14c or even 15c in southern england throughout. The record December is nailed on now its just a question of how high the cet ends up.


I know many are looking at 10 days a fortnight ahead but having just watched Alex Dekins forecast on BBC weather,he says there is no sign of any change as we go into 2016 and more of the same to come in early January.Its way too early to get excited.

Whether Idle
25 December 2015 20:08:14


Hmm I just can't shift the feelinh this place is going to be suicidal hot pot in the coming days... #imstillnotbuyintoit 


Originally Posted by: picturesareme 


You may say that.  All people are doing is commenting on the model output as it stands at a moment in time (incidentally, this is why quoting people out of temporal context is a zero sum game).  I think we've all been here enough times before to realise that this easterly probably wont come off.  But the chance is there and it will be discussed.  I think these charts offer a real antidote to 12c and drizzle.  Its ridiculously warm outside now, people are just getting conditioned to it, these charts are at least showing the possibility of an alternative.  Its 2015 NOT 2005 and I think a lot of the punters on here are grown up enough to handle whatever the model output can throw at them.


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
Arcus
25 December 2015 20:09:17

Despite all the eye candy FI charts the MetO are having none of it with no change to their mild outlook until at least mid January.


Andy

Originally Posted by: Andy Woodcock 


The MetO follow and interpret the model output, not vice-versa 


Ben,
Nr. Easingwold, North Yorkshire
30m asl
Maunder Minimum
25 December 2015 20:16:15


Even if doesn't come off, this is the kind of excitement that we enjoy - great to have it emerging around Christmas. 


Anyone know when the ensembles come out for ECM? And the GFSP? Should be interesting. 


Happy xmas all, enjoy the family fallouts from articulate


fingers crossed for a new year change of fortunes in the weather! 


Originally Posted by: ITSY 


Great to see some eastern promise in the charts - now we just have to hope that they are not merely an artefact of lack of data over Christmas. We need to see things firm up over the next couple of days and then I shall believe!


 


New world order coming.
pdiddy
25 December 2015 20:22:43


I think the main thing to point out is that the METO don't even see the possibility of a battle in their medium term outlook, perhaps the models are overreacting to the MJO uncertainty, whereas of course we know that the ENSO and immense PV can overwhelm this factor.


 


The ECM 32 dayer remains very progressive through to the end of January.


 


Merry Xmas everyone 


Originally Posted by: Shropshire 


I'm not sure this is the main thing... I think a lot of experienced posters will be looking for a combination cross-model support and run to run consistency (which we have not yet had) as the main support for cold synoptics developing in a reliable timeframe.  If the MetO/ECm 32 had been bang on the money previously with their forecasts, they would have a greater following... we will all wait and see how this develops.  It would be great if you cud support your theories with evidence as it would help us all learn.


...and a merry christmas to you Shropshire!


 

David M Porter
25 December 2015 20:23:40


I think the main thing to point out is that the METO don't even see the possibility of a battle in their medium term outlook, perhaps the models are overreacting to the MJO uncertainty, whereas of course we know that the ENSO and immense PV can overwhelm this factor.


 


The ECM 32 dayer remains very progressive through to the end of January.


 


Merry Xmas everyone 


Originally Posted by: Shropshire 


As I said above, of the models continue with runs like this over the coming few days, I suspect they may have to tear up their medium range outlook and the ECM 32 day forecast will likely change. Both are only reflecting what the various models, including those the MetO have access to that we don't are showing at a given time.


As for the PV, I read either earlier in this thread or the previous one that the PV actually is not as strong at the moment as it has been in other recent winters, notably 2013/14 when it remained very strong throughout that season.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"Let us not take ourselves too seriously. None of us has a monopoly on wisdom, and we must always be ready to listen and respect other points of view."- Queen Elizabeth II 1926-2022
25 December 2015 20:35:47

Not surprisingly the ECM op run is an outlier at the end of the run. Mind you it does have the control run for company.


http://www.weerstationgrou.nl/pluim/

Gandalf The White
25 December 2015 20:44:24


Not surprisingly the ECM op run is an outlier at the end of the run. Mind you it does have the control run for company.


http://www.weerstationgrou.nl/pluim/


Originally Posted by: Global Warming 


The ensemble mean chart for Day 10 suggests that the MetO long-range forecasts won't be changing yet.



Very good support for a block but it's 1,000 miles too far east and we're left under the eastern end of the Atlantic conveyor belt. I would guess that unless the ensemble suite pulls everything west the professionals won't make any change to the current outlook.


 


Location: South Cambridgeshire
130 metres ASL
52.0N 0.1E


Whether Idle
25 December 2015 20:52:15


 


The ensemble mean chart for Day 10 suggests that the MetO long-range forecasts won't be changing yet.


 


Very good support for a block but it's 1,000 miles too far east and we're left under the eastern end of the Atlantic conveyor belt. I would guess that unless the ensemble suite pulls everything west the professionals won't make any change to the current outlook.


 


Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


The ensembles suggest a cold scenario for NW Europe in 10 days is not likely, as we all suspected.  But there is a small possibility, which should be decided by the end of the weekend.


Here's the ens, as GW said, the control and the op both go cold but they are in a breakaway cluster rather than with the main "flock" of runs.



Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
GlenH
25 December 2015 21:27:44
While ensemble data is important for understanding the stability / likelihood of particular patterns, it shouldn't be forgotten that the operational runs are, in theory at least, more likely to be accurate than any of the individual ensemble runs.
Quantum
25 December 2015 21:28:07


Parallel GFS 12Z allies with the ECM and brings in frigid winds from the SE


2023/2024 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):
29/11 (-6), 30/11 (-6), 02/12 (-5), 03/12 (-5), 04/12 (-3), 16/01 (-3), 18/01 (-8), 08/02 (-5)

Total: 8 days with snow/sleet falling.

2022/2023 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):

18/12 (-1), 06/03 (-6), 08/03 (-8), 09/03 (-6), 10/03 (-8), 11/03 (-5), 14/03 (-6)

Total: 7 days with snow/sleet falling.

2021/2022 Snow days (approx 850hpa temp):

26/11 (-5), 27/11 (-7), 28/11 (-6), 02/12 (-6), 06/01 (-5), 07/01 (-6), 06/02 (-5), 19/02 (-5), 24/02 (-7), 30/03 (-7), 31/03 (-8), 01/04 (-8)
Total: 12 days with snow/sleet falling.
David M Porter
25 December 2015 21:30:57


 


The ensemble mean chart for Day 10 suggests that the MetO long-range forecasts won't be changing yet.



Very good support for a block but it's 1,000 miles too far east and we're left under the eastern end of the Atlantic conveyor belt. I would guess that unless the ensemble suite pulls everything west the professionals won't make any change to the current outlook.


 


Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


Although still unsettled, that ECM mean chart seems to suggest to me anyway that temps might be more likely to return to closer to average values, rather than the exceptional mildness we have seen at times in recent weeks. Pressure over central & southern Europe doesn't look to be as high either, as has often been the case recently.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"Let us not take ourselves too seriously. None of us has a monopoly on wisdom, and we must always be ready to listen and respect other points of view."- Queen Elizabeth II 1926-2022
Solar Cycles
25 December 2015 21:31:40


 


Not sure it's a widespread snow event it's very close to one though. An excellent run nonetheless .


 


 


Originally Posted by: Ally Pally Snowman 

Solar Cycles
25 December 2015 21:38:29


ECM is very snowy. I have drawn the fronts on the 192hr onwards. 


frontse


At 192 we have the first potential area of snow, this one is not coming into particularly cold air so it is pretty uncertain. However evaporation cooling may turn the precipitation on this very slow moving front to snow. If it does this is potentially a 10cm event, since the front is still there 24 hours later (see 216 image).


At 216 we have a rapidly occluding low moving gradually north east. This is a classic warm occlusion and will dump ALOT of snow, and yes it will be completely snow for everywhere north of the triple point, and potentially snow for those east of the warm front. This occluded front is also slow-moving and its remnants can be seen on the 240hr image. This one could drop 15-20cm locally. Parts of the North midlands, Wales, NW england, SW scotland and N ireland would be in the firing line for this. 


At 240 we have yet another feature moving up from the south, this an occluded front wrapping around a secluded warm centre. Again this could drop several cm in a very narrow band for parts of the midlands. In the 240hr image we would also have lake effect snow to contend with for SE England. 


 


Also noteworthy the polar front (boundry between polar and sub tropical airmasses) becomes increasingly well defined. Note how it moves very far south. At 192hours its the same latitude as newfoundland and the UK, by 216hours it stretches on a long SW to NE trajectory ending in SW England and by 240 hours it stretches right across the atlantic to the mediteranian.


 


 


Originally Posted by: Quantum 

Juat playing catch up now and boy that's one evolution I would like to bank right now, it has a certain 78/79 look about it but what looks even better is all that WAA being pumped Polewards. A truly fantastic output, now for the tricky bit getting it in the reliable timeframe.😁

Gandalf The White
25 December 2015 21:43:56

While ensemble data is important for understanding the stability / likelihood of particular patterns, it shouldn't be forgotten that the operational runs are, in theory at least, more likely to be accurate than any of the individual ensemble runs.

Originally Posted by: GlenH 


But the point is uncertainties grow as the run progresses and the Op isn't likely to produce the most probable outcome.  The way the charts for the final days chop and change demonstrates that very well.  Therefore we have to look at ensemble patterns - and the accompanying spreads - for indications of the strength of the operational evolution.


Location: South Cambridgeshire
130 metres ASL
52.0N 0.1E


TimS
  • TimS
  • Advanced Member
25 December 2015 21:48:53

It's been interesting watching these model runs producing cold Easterlies after weeks of strong Westerlies, but I'm now thinking this is perhaps one of the features of cold spells in generally positive NAO periods like now.

January 1987 was an isolated Easterly in a zonal winter. February 1991 likewise, right in the middle of the most positive NAO multi year period in my lifetime. In both cases weeks and weeks of roaring westerlies with low heights over Greenland are replaced, not by a mid Atlantic or Greenland high, but by a rise in pressure over Scandinavia. In both cases the westerlies come back quite quickly afterwards abs normal service is resumed.

In more sustained cold winters (early 80s, 2009-11) we instead see a much weakened jet and Greenland highs.


Brockley, South East London 30m asl
Andy Woodcock
25 December 2015 21:55:21


 


That is though stunning Happy Christmas from the ECM !


 


Originally Posted by: Ally Pally Snowman 


Christ! I must issue WIO posts more often, my latest was just 2 days ago when the charts looked very different, however, nothing has verified yet and the MetO ain't convinced, we will see but as I said 2 days ago I am more than happy to be proved totally wrong.


Andy


 


Andy Woodcock
Penrith
Cumbria

Altitude 535 feet

"Why are the British so worried about climate change? Any change to their climate can only be an improvement" John Daley 2001
Gooner
25 December 2015 22:01:04

Posted in Media thread


A Deakin not even considering and Easterly for the next 10 days or so


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus
Banbury
North Oxfordshire
378 feet A S L


Andy Woodcock
25 December 2015 22:03:51

While ensemble data is important for understanding the stability / likelihood of particular patterns, it shouldn't be forgotten that the operational runs are, in theory at least, more likely to be accurate than any of the individual ensemble runs.

Originally Posted by: GlenH 


That is worth remembering, how many times do we see non operational or control runs pump out whacky cold charts that never verify, maybe tonight they are just whacky mild ones?


I would rather have one good operational than 10 other members.



Andy


Andy Woodcock
Penrith
Cumbria

Altitude 535 feet

"Why are the British so worried about climate change? Any change to their climate can only be an improvement" John Daley 2001
Andy Woodcock
25 December 2015 22:07:05


 


Although still unsettled, that ECM mean chart seems to suggest to me anyway that temps might be more likely to return to closer to average values, rather than the exceptional mildness we have seen at times in recent weeks. Pressure over central & southern Europe doesn't look to be as high either, as has often been the case recently.


Originally Posted by: David M Porter 


Actually after the south westerly crap we have had over the past 8 weeks that mean charts says cold zonality which would suit me fine, things are looking better lets just hope it's not a Christmas illusion.


Andy


Andy Woodcock
Penrith
Cumbria

Altitude 535 feet

"Why are the British so worried about climate change? Any change to their climate can only be an improvement" John Daley 2001
GlenH
25 December 2015 22:19:16


 


But the point is uncertainties grow as the run progresses and the Op isn't likely to produce the most probable outcome.  

Originally Posted by: Gandalf The White 


 


I'm not sure that entirely makes sense. The uncertainty is contained entirely within the model. The actual future is, at least according to our current understanding of macro-scale systems, entirely deterministic. There is only one outcome - what will happen. If the model is a good approximation of the system then the 'operational' run (i.e. the run with the most accurate and largest data set) will, on average, produce the best forecast. The perturbated ensemble set gives an indication of the sensitivity of both the model (to data inaccuracy) and modelled system (to the starting conditions). So, I'm in no way suggesting that ensemble forecasting is not useful - it's extremely important to modern forecasting, but this is because in some circumstances it provides a way of working around the inaccuracies and limitations of data collection and model design / computation. The usefulness of the ensemble set does however vary, depending on the atmospheric state at the start of the model simulation. 

Remove ads from site

Ads