Remove ads from site

radiohead
24 November 2014 16:03:07


 


It's the same model as the 0z, 12z and 18z so how can that be the case?


Originally Posted by: Brian Gaze 


 


Exactly Brian. It's the same model, the same software run on the same hardware. The only difference being the starting conditions are updated with each run. So there really isn't any way that a certain type of pattern or bias can appear on the 06Z versus the other runs.


The old story about the 06Z and 18Z getting out of date radiosonde data is a myth that was debunked by the NCEP on the US weather forums a couple of years ago :


 

I have no idea what you mean when you say that the radiosonde data is "out of date" for 6z and 18z. At NCEP, we (currently) use a 3D analysis scheme with a 6 hour time window. If you use 12z as an example, we only assimilate observations that are taken between 09z and 15z, for that given analysis. There are ways to use observations within a longer time window, and actually take their time information (and propagation) into account (4DVAR)


We look at these models so much that we start projecting personalities into them I think.


 

colin46
24 November 2014 16:07:40

http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/archive/ra/1963/Rrea00119630131.gif


shine on you crazy diamond
192.104 m / 630.262 feet ASL
Russwirral
24 November 2014 16:12:53
https://max.nwstatic.co.uk/gfsimages/gfs.20141124/12/129/h850t850eu.png 

im really expecting that pool of warmth off in the eastern med to kick something off in our favour over that way... but its doing nothing.

Perhaps it needs a shot of cold from the north to stir things up a bit first.

As a result its stale mate with continued HP with mild uppers diddling about in no mans land over us. Almost there GFS... almost there.
nsrobins
24 November 2014 16:48:57


Hi all, I am new here. My first post


As far as I know there are two routine radiosonde launches every day at 0000 UTC and 1200 UTC which are included in the 00z and 12z runs. Therefore those runs include actual updated atmospheric data. It could well be that the 6z and 18z tend to the default mode as per the absence of real data... and consequently the 00z and 12z should be more reliable... I'm just guessing here guys


 


 


 


Originally Posted by: Gorgo 


A very warm welcome (or should I say mild). I think someone has already described how the 6hr interval models don't suffer from irregularities in dropsonde data as it's 'virtualised' from previous sets - in other words, even the interpolated data is as good as the actual readings when required. Add to that the fact that dropsonde parameters are only a percentage of the cohort that gets input and I tend to go along with the theory that model 'bias' is a myth and very subjective.


There are of course situations when chucks of data are missing or sections of the algorithm have not performed to well, but these are reported in statements and can (and often are) used as excuses when the models don't show what you're expecting them to show. For example, a classic flip from cold to mild on Boxing Day will be put down to the lack of transatlantic flights and data missing from lighthouses where the keepers have had one to many sherries


Neil
Fareham, Hampshire 28m ASL (near estuary)
Stormchaser, Member TORRO
sizzle
24 November 2014 16:58:38

  hope its not a red herring. we get close to cold/ snow then we get cheated with a blow torch bartlett azores high spanish plume.

Brian Gaze
24 November 2014 16:59:11

12z GFS op and GFSP both follow the 6z with the Atlantic smashing through quite easily.


 


Brian Gaze
Berkhamsted
TWO Buzz - get the latest news and views 
"I'm not socialist, I know that. I don't believe in sharing my money." - Gary Numan
Stormchaser
24 November 2014 17:09:13

Yes, welcome to the forum Gorgo, just in time for the dramatic season 


 


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gfse_cartes.php?ech=204&code=code&mode=0&mode3h=0&runpara=0&carte=1


Try running that lot through (192 to 384) hours... there are so many circulations going on that it can be a bit nauseating!


What's happening is the polar vortex losing the ability to bundle the energy up across Canada and Greenland, with areas of cold Arctic air flying around all over the place, along with remnants of the polar vortex, one of which pays the UK a fair old visit - but not in the right place for a snowfest I'm afraid.


That remnant remains quite well consolidated for much of lower-res, and only in the final stages of the run do we see the low heights dividing as the jet dives all the way down to Africa. High pressure can then develop to the north of the UK but really this run makes a hard job of things as far as getting some proper cold to the UK is concerned.


 


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gfse_cartes.php?ech=204&code=code&mode=0&mode3h=0&runpara=1&carte=1&runpara=1


The parallel version has a lot of similarities, but works out a bit better in terms of the outlook beyond day 16, thanks to less in the way of low heights making it from the Pacific to Canada.


Despite this, we could really do with the jet being weaker and tracking further south.


 


Some relief, then, that if there's one thing both GFS and GFSP tend to do, it's overcook the Atlantic jet. I've reached this conclusion regarding GFSP after making a note of what it showed for the coming week back on 14th November; a raging jet with countless storms blasting through the UK bringing strong winds and many spells of rain.


Instead, we have this:


No chart available for the selected hour. Many charts start at 3 hours ahead, so if you have 0 hours selected try stepping forward or selecting a later hour.


 


Facepalm for GFSP, fist pump for those seeking a colder setup for the first week or so of December! 


 


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 
2023's Homeland Extremes:
T-Max: 30.2°C 9th Sep (...!) | T-Min: -7.1°C 22nd & 23rd Jan | Wettest Day: 25.9mm 2nd Nov | Ice Days: 1 (2nd Dec -1.3°C in freezing fog)
Keep Calm and Forecast On
LA2B MeridFlowEuro09
24 November 2014 17:59:11

 


The last week (7 days to be precise - ugh... Almost). We have El Niño Pattern Reload, Wave 2 ahem.


The jet stream splits with Cold air arriving to Europe Central and East side, Low dives South across W then SW Europe briefly give a few days Azores to Europe High link up UK get SE then East winds, as shown on UKMO, GFS thereafter following next Sunday relaxed weather, has North Atlantic Low move NE to Norwegian Sea to North NE Europe corner, some of this Low Pressure in week after This weekend should affect UK on its SW flanks, but always we look often seeing High Preesure from the SE or SW with NW flow followed by SW and then Calm settled spells, but at times UK is looking Windy and wet with both sectors of mild and also colder showery NW intrusions.


The UKMO 120 and 144 and the 96 hrs chart show some very cold airmass for Central E Europe, with North Atlantic and Norwegian Sea Low on a more northerly track with moves from West  to NE, over much of Europe in general, SW Europe and NW Africa inc. S of Bay of Biscay is Low Pressure shown to bring a lot of chilly cool and wet or showery and thundery weather there.


That includes Morocco and Tunisa west.


The pattern is based on a less cold set up with Cyclonic fast moving Northern Low Pressure areas, with large Blocking High's affecting Areas to their South SW and SE, so they keep stagnating in sync with mobile North Atlantic NE Europe and Arctic Norwegian Sea Low Pressure systems, west to NE in general.


GFS does offer opportunities for some pulses from the NW Atlantic SE Greenland at times from the West sides of each UK tracking Low the GFS shows, but UKMO at 96,120 and 144 has us in High Pressure with either SE or easterly winds and that is meridian blocking/ Continental weather/ mild bringer!.


Climate is warming up, Scotland and N Ireland and North England still often gets some Winter frost, ice and snow, November to March, but the SE and South UK including S Central England and Wales, together with the West and North through the year, they sometimes get more rain than London and S SE England, where some longer dry fine spells without much heavy rain is seen every year.

The North Atlantic Sea often gets some much Colder Wintry conditions from November to March Months, and Mild SW and South winds tend to be more frequent over the East and SE of North Atlantic Sea, as the Azores High tends to stay in charge. 

With this warmth and heat, the Central and South UK has become mostly free of snow and frost.
Ally Pally Snowman
24 November 2014 18:23:36


http://www.theweatheroutlook.com/charts/gefs/7_336_850tmp.png?cb=733


 


P7 delivers snowmageddon on the 6z GEFS


 


 


Originally Posted by: Russwirral 


 


Yes not bad prefer P17 though snowmageddon again


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gefs_cartes.php?code=17&ech=336&mode=0&carte=0


 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Russwirral
24 November 2014 18:29:53


 


 


Yes not bad prefer P17 though snowmageddon again


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gefs_cartes.php?code=17&ech=336&mode=0&carte=0


 


Originally Posted by: Ally Pally Snowman 


(raises an eyebrow)



Ally Pally Snowman
24 November 2014 18:37:16

Snowy GEM as well for the SE.


http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Rgem2282.html


 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Gooner
24 November 2014 19:06:18

http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/ecmwf/runs/2014112412/ECH1-192.GIF?24-0


This wont be mild at all


Remember anything after T120 is really Just For Fun



Marcus
Banbury
North Oxfordshire
378 feet A S L


sizzle
24 November 2014 19:13:53

first week of december 1995 rings a bell that was very cold and snowy. these are cracking charts, too far out for me to get to excited, lets see what the next few days bring could be over cooked or evan a red herring,

Ally Pally Snowman
24 November 2014 19:20:36


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/ecmwf/runs/2014112412/ECH1-192.GIF?24-0


This wont be mild at all


Originally Posted by: Gooner 


 


Excellent JMA as well. Very good output it has to be said tonight.


 


http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/Rjma1921.html


 


 


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Whether Idle
24 November 2014 19:23:33

Day 6 JMA



Day 8 JMA:



Quite a few signals supporting some kind of easterly outbreak by early December.  Interesting times, jet and synoptics are interesting particularly, as they are quite odd.


Dover, 5m asl. Half a mile from the south coast.
Ally Pally Snowman
24 November 2014 19:23:58

Coldest GFS ensembles of the winter so far some very wintry efforts there.


http://www.wetterzentrale.de/pics/MT8_London_ens.png


Bishop's Stortford 85m ASL.
Polar Low
24 November 2014 19:51:49

Perhaps the means are more useful in a more realistic time scale with such uncertainty at the moment


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/gefs_cartes.php?ech=144&code=21&mode=0&carte=1


 


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/cmc_cartes.php?code=21&ech=144&mode=0&carte=1


 


 

roger63
24 November 2014 20:19:31

The encouraging thing is that some of the output now has the HP to the east further north.However  around 240 h the majority of GEFS  ENS are Atlantic flows.

Stormchaser
24 November 2014 20:51:46

 


It doesn't take a genius to spot the major short-term difference between GFS/GFSP and the rest of the models:


Modele UKMO - Carte prévisions   Modele UKMO - Carte prévisions


UKMO: large Iberian trough as a robust cut-off feature.                   ECM: large Iberian trough as a robust cut-off feature.


Modele UKMO - Carte prévisions   Modele UKMO - Carte prévisions


JMA: large Iberian/French trough as a robust cut-off feature.            GEM: large western Med. trough as a robust cut-off feature.


Modele UKMO - Carte prévisions   Modele UKMO - Carte prévisions


GFS and GFSP: smaller Iberian trough that struggles to separate from the Atlantic jet stream.


 


What gives?


Answer: the jet is stronger than the other models have it even at just 4 days range. The upstream Atlantic troughs push east too quickly for the Azores High to build a 'bridge' of higher pressure to the north of the low that's diving south of the UK.


So, given the agreement between the other models and that this includes the most reliable of them all in the 4 day range, it seems likely that this is a classic case of GFS overcooking the jet, and it's a shame to find this, but the upgraded version appears to have the same trait and in fact it could be concluded from the above that the tendency might be even more pronounced!


I have seen comments on other forums indicating that the GFSP has a few problems with it, which should be amended prior to it's full take-over from the current GFS. I'm hoping this overcooking of the jet is one of those that will be sorted!


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 
2023's Homeland Extremes:
T-Max: 30.2°C 9th Sep (...!) | T-Min: -7.1°C 22nd & 23rd Jan | Wettest Day: 25.9mm 2nd Nov | Ice Days: 1 (2nd Dec -1.3°C in freezing fog)
Keep Calm and Forecast On
kmoorman
24 November 2014 20:54:50


 


It doesn't take a genius to spot the major short-term difference between GFS/GFSP and the rest of the models:


  


UKMO: large Iberian trough as a robust cut-off feature.                   ECM: large Iberian trough as a robust cut-off feature.


  


JMA: large Iberian/French trough as a robust cut-off feature.            GEM: large western Med. trough as a robust cut-off feature.


  


GFS and GFSP: smaller Iberian trough that struggles to separate from the Atlantic jet stream.


 


What gives?


Answer: the jet is stronger than the other models have it even at just 4 days range. The upstream Atlantic troughs push east too quickly for the Azores High to build a 'bridge' of higher pressure to the north of the low that's diving south of the UK.


So, given the agreement between the other models and that this includes the most reliable of them all in the 4 day range, it seems likely that this is a classic case of GFS overcooking the jet, and it's a shame to find this, but the upgraded version appears to have the same trait and in fact it could be concluded from the above that the tendency might be even more pronounced!


I have seen comments on other forums indicating that the GFSP has a few problems with it, which should be amended prior to it's full take-over from the current GFS. I'm hoping this overcooking of the jet is one of those that will be sorted!


Originally Posted by: Stormchaser 


 


Let's hope so, eh?   Which model has the best verification stats at that range currently?


Home: Durrington, Worthing, West Sussex. (16 ASL)
Work: Canary Wharf, London
Follow me on Twitter @kmoorman1968
White Meadows
24 November 2014 21:06:56
ECM was for a long time widely regarded as the form horse in recent years. Last December (or was it the one before?) it lead many up the garden path for days with a classic easterly set up which was suddenly dropped approx T-96hrs. The end result was a euro high and lots of head scratching was followed by increasing faith in gfs and, Ukmo aside other lesser models.

Ecm took a dent that winter so I'm for one personally keen to see if gfsp can push ecm down in the verification stats.
Stormchaser
24 November 2014 21:08:32

If anyone has a link to the latest verification stats I would be most grateful 


 


A brief note on the longer term - ECM has backed off from the very fast movement of the Greenland lobe into the Atlantic that was present on the previous two op runs, and in that sense has brought the pace of events more in line with GFS/GFSP.


This leaves the blocking to east as once again the main source of uncertainty in the output for the first week of December. JMA makes by far the most of that, but this comes from the Atlantic troughs making less progress east as early as day 4 when compared to ECM and UKMO, and it would be quite something for that duo to have that modeled incorrectly at such short range when they are in agreement.


 


The stronger Iberian trough supports a stronger blocking high on the ECM run than what GFS and GFSP go for, and it's fair to assume that UKMO would head the same way, though perhaps the high wouldn't be quite so extensive.


GEM could have followed suit, but deepens the Atlantic storms more than the other models, resulting in a messy - though actually snowy for some - battleground scenario rather than the blocking high in full control.


 


The theme of recent months has been that blocking to the east holding on in the face of longer-range projections for it to fall, so I'm starting to settle on the theme of a blocking high to our east and a slowly disintegrating polar vortex lobe in the Atlantic - allowing lows to slide down to the Med. - as the favoured way forward.


Now just watch tomorrow's models change tracks completely 


 


If you have any problems or queries relating to TWO you can Email [email protected]

https://twitter.com/peacockreports 
2023's Homeland Extremes:
T-Max: 30.2°C 9th Sep (...!) | T-Min: -7.1°C 22nd & 23rd Jan | Wettest Day: 25.9mm 2nd Nov | Ice Days: 1 (2nd Dec -1.3°C in freezing fog)
Keep Calm and Forecast On
tallyho_83
24 November 2014 21:18:10


http://www.meteociel.fr/modeles/ecmwf/runs/2014112412/ECH1-192.GIF?24-0


This wont be mild at all


Originally Posted by: Gooner 


North easterly winds~!! - I do believe that there are some interesting things that are starting to develop post 10 days.


Even if this turns out to be a milder winter - it won't be as wet as last year - looking at the models/gfs etc there is no real deepening low and relentless low pressure system after system - the models certainly are not showing this - it's all very vague and the Atlantic looks set to be quieter - at least for now.


Just worth a watch deep into FI: - perfect set up for an easterly before Xmas:


 http://modeles.meteociel.fr/modeles/cfs/runs/2014112312/run/cfs-0-684.png?12


Home Location - Kellands Lane, Okehampton, Devon (200m ASL)
---------------------------------------
Sean Moon
Magical Moon
www.magical-moon.com


David M Porter
24 November 2014 21:19:31

ECM was for a long time widely regarded as the form horse in recent years. Last December (or was it the one before?) it lead many up the garden path for days with a classic easterly set up which was suddenly dropped approx T-96hrs. The end result was a euro high and lots of head scratching was followed by increasing faith in gfs and, Ukmo aside other lesser models.

Ecm took a dent that winter so I'm for one personally keen to see if gfsp can push ecm down in the verification stats.

Originally Posted by: White Meadows 


I reckon it is December 2012 you are thinking of there WM. I could be wrong, but I have no clear recollection of the ECM, or any of the other models, showing an easterly of any sorts at any stage during last December. My recollection of last year is that in the early part of December, the models initially showed high pressure controlling the weather for much of the month although never really that cold, before the breakdown to atlantic dominance that went on to last until after mid-Feb was picked up.


December 2012 did have quite a few cold days here in the first half of that month, and during that time I do remember some pretty interesting model runs on a few occasions. The second half of that December was milder and wetter but that wasn't to set the tone for the rest of the winter; IIRC the model runs in the first few days of 2013 clearly indicated that a change in pattern was afoot.


Lenzie, Glasgow

"Let us not take ourselves too seriously. None of us has a monopoly on wisdom, and we must always be ready to listen and respect other points of view."- Queen Elizabeth II 1926-2022

Remove ads from site

Ads