I've already got a bad feeling about losing this toss...
Originally Posted by: Matty H
I'm more concerned about the way the selectors have treated this game as an experiment when they had a chance to ram home the advantage. Why give this shower a sniff when there's another series away coming up? Listening to TMS and they are being extremely critical. The texts coming in from people that have bought tickets for the game is pretty damning too. The ECB have been forced to respond. They said this was their best available 11, which is complete bollox I'm afraid. Not impressed.
Originally Posted by: turbotubbs
Agreed
Kerrigan isn't ready and needs to learn his craft more. Woakes I'm not convinced is good enough full stop (certainly not with the ball)
Saying that, I'm happy they've took the decision to 'rest' Bairstow. I just think they needed to bring in a different replacement. I suspect Root, now under less pressure (Ashes won) will knock a half-century score, after surviving some twitchy moments, and the selectors will tickle each other's todgers and smugly tell everyone how right they were that he's an opener (and he'll then struggle again when we go Down Under)
I would of course have Root in the side - he's a class batsman. Just not as an opener, and we lose too much reliability in the middle order by shifting him from there. He also, as we've seen, has the ability to be a second twirler.
I'd have gone for an attack of Anderson, Broad, Tremlett & Swann
Ideally I'd have brought in a new opener and moved Root back to 6. But apart from Compton (who England seem to have dismissed completely as an option), there's no other opener really anywhere near the England set-up. So, if the England selectors were determined to take a look at Woakes, and aren't ever going to move Root from opening the batting, then Woakes for Bairstow seemed the obvious move. That way, his bowling, which isn't his real forte, wouldn't be under as much pressure as the third seamer; he'd just be back-up behind the three main seamers. With Root as back-up spinner.
Martin
Home: St Helens (26m asl) Work: Manchester (75m asl)
A TWO addict since 14/12/01
"How can wealth persuade poverty to use its political freedom to keep wealth in power? Here lies the whole art of Conservative politics."
Aneurin Bevan